SOLVED Bitwarden - Self-hosted password manager
LDAP support is a Work in Progress right now.
The plan is not to have it leverage LDAP for auth, but to auto invite users from LDAP so that new user registration doesn't have to be enabled.
To answer my own question: no Cloudron still does not support multi stage builds:
08:07 $ docker build . Sending build context to Docker daemon 7.68kB Step 1/12 : FROM cloudron/base:1.0.0@sha256:147a648a068a2e746644746bbfb42eb7a50d682437cead3c67c933c546357617 sha256:147a648a068a2e746644746bbfb42eb7a50d682437cead3c67c933c546357617: Pulling from cloudron/base 124c757242f8: Pull complete 9d866f8bde2a: Pull complete fa3f2f277e67: Pull complete 398d32b153e8: Pull complete afde35469481: Pull complete 5fa763ad3e3d: Pull complete 6f382df2868f: Pull complete da8db3680a7d: Pull complete bbf6e101d755: Pull complete ba1148a00c9f: Pull complete 7b84d63a4591: Pull complete Digest: sha256:147a648a068a2e746644746bbfb42eb7a50d682437cead3c67c933c546357617 Status: Downloaded newer image for cloudron/base:1.0.0@sha256:147a648a068a2e746644746bbfb42eb7a50d682437cead3c67c933c546357617 ---> 534bd0efda10 Step 2/12 : ENV ROCKET_ENV "staging" ---> Running in 68b6aa46c8fe Removing intermediate container 68b6aa46c8fe ---> b5146c0012ce Step 3/12 : ENV ROCKET_PORT=80 ---> Running in 3ceb3ae20f44 Removing intermediate container 3ceb3ae20f44 ---> 20f1c76798d9 Step 4/12 : ENV ROCKET_WORKERS=10 ---> Running in fb4da112f345 Removing intermediate container fb4da112f345 ---> 4715e7e5db66 Step 5/12 : RUN mkdir -p /app/data ---> Running in 080caeccf4bc Removing intermediate container 080caeccf4bc ---> 3bc89f3dd8e3 Step 6/12 : VOLUME /app/data ---> Running in c14ec82d1d86 Removing intermediate container c14ec82d1d86 ---> 921426c4b462 Step 7/12 : EXPOSE 80 ---> Running in 6f8a51fa17c2 Removing intermediate container 6f8a51fa17c2 ---> 945b85a9d2c0 Step 8/12 : EXPOSE 3012 ---> Running in 57a9f4770437 Removing intermediate container 57a9f4770437 ---> 29bf7e9ddc35 Step 9/12 : COPY --from=mprasil/bitwarden:1.7.0 /web-vault /app/code/web-vault 1.7.0: Pulling from mprasil/bitwarden 6ae821421a7d: Pull complete 6b62744e37c4: Pull complete 6f7d0f488d72: Pull complete b1dac5a36400: Pull complete f5334a919416: Pull complete 86593ec71a37: Pull complete Digest: sha256:0d48e5b8f64d83a0d0931aba0fb559985a687b7417ceb49fb909051b0f397f47 Status: Downloaded newer image for mprasil/bitwarden:1.7.0 ---> 8362350b2ff1 Step 10/12 : COPY --from=mprasil/bitwarden:1.7.0 /bitwarden_rs /app/code/ ---> d6e0b6fc0c46 Step 11/12 : COPY --from=mprasil/bitwarden:1.7.0 /Rocket.toml /app/code/ ---> e835acd7031b Step 12/12 : CMD /app/code/bitwarden_rs ---> Running in 81f78757da52 Removing intermediate container 81f78757da52 ---> 89d5017a81f4 Successfully built 89d5017a81f4 ✔ ~/.../bitwarden_rs/cloudron [cloudron L|✔] 08:09 $ cloudron build Building email@example.com Build scheduled with id bc08173c-2af9-4f3f-a759-19d60bb45cf8 Waiting for build to begin, this may take a bit... Step 1/12 : FROM cloudron/base:1.0.0@sha256:147a648a068a2e746644746bbfb42eb7a50d682437cead3c67c933c546357617 ---> 534bd0efda10 Step 2/12 : ENV ROCKET_ENV "staging" ---> Using cache ---> c5a9b7d6ac6f Step 3/12 : ENV ROCKET_PORT 80 ---> Using cache ---> 2d22bcf6dc7d Step 4/12 : ENV ROCKET_WORKERS 10 ---> Using cache ---> 2e5e855777d5 Step 5/12 : RUN mkdir -p /app/data ---> Using cache ---> 2688a8102e91 Step 6/12 : VOLUME /app/data ---> Using cache ---> 4ee6f1df5ccf Step 7/12 : EXPOSE 80 ---> Using cache ---> 5f451061f3e1 Step 8/12 : EXPOSE 3012 ---> Using cache ---> 8c5e8e7a13b4 Step 9/12 : COPY --from=mprasil/bitwarden:1.7.0 /web-vault /app/code/web-vault Unknown flag: from Build failed Build failed ERROR App could not be built due to errors above [ /usr/lib/node_modules/cloudron/src/helper.js:68:29 ]
While a standalone ``docker build .` succeeds doing it via ´cloudron build´ fails.
LDAP support is a Work in Progress right now.
I would say even the recently introduced admin panel is already a good step. This could be secured via http basic auth and only allowed for admins in Cloudron. The last point in the ldap sync topic was afair that this will be implemented as a standalone tool (which then will give the challenge on how to integrate both parts in the same image).
@fbartels The tool will likely be written as a static binary which can be downloaded and installed within the same container. Then it can be executed by Cloudron using the scheduler. Roughly the same way other periodic tasks are executed.
Is there chance Bitwarden is going to be included in cloudron soon ?
I would like to start using it.
Docker has recently been updated on the cloudron buildserver, which means multi stage builds and
COPY --fromnow works within Dockerfiles.
I have a longer train ride on friday, maybe I can now make something happen with Bitwarden_rs.
basic prototype now lives in https://git.cloudron.io/fbartels/bitwardenrs-app
cannot build it at the moment, though. since its stuck at
$ cloudron build Building firstname.lastname@example.org Build scheduled with id 9fcf31f1-04f9-445e-b687-79b2f7d54659 Waiting for build to begin, this may take a bit...
@girish is the backend maybe hanging?
edit: by now the build has finished
necrevistonnezr last edited by necrevistonnezr
Great that this is being worked on!
I installed the app but get the following errors:
Mar 23 10:36:17 box:shell addLogrotateConfig spawn: /usr/bin/sudo -S /home/yellowtent/box/src/scripts/configurelogrotate.sh add a3cda43e-541b-4edd-b8fe-c4cfb52752fb /tmp/a3cda43e-541b-4edd-b8fe-c4cfb52752fb.logrotate Mar 23 10:27:12 => Starting bitwarden_rs Mar 23 10:27:12 [2019-03-23 10:27:12][bitwarden_rs][ERROR] Error creating database directory Mar 23 10:27:16 => Starting bitwarden_rs Mar 23 10:27:16 [2019-03-23 10:27:16][bitwarden_rs][ERROR] Error creating database directory Mar 23 10:27:19 => Starting bitwarden_rs Mar 23 10:27:19 [2019-03-23 10:27:19][bitwarden_rs][ERROR] Error creating database directory Mar 23 10:27:22 => Starting bitwarden_rs Mar 23 10:27:22 [2019-03-23 10:27:22][bitwarden_rs][ERROR] Error creating database directory Mar 23 10:27:26 => Starting bitwarden_rs Mar 23 10:27:26 [2019-03-23 10:27:26][bitwarden_rs][ERROR] Error creating database directory Mar 23 10:27:30 => Starting bitwarden_rs
After restarting the app it's now
sudo systemctl restart boxas well.
@fbartels It works now with the fix from my colleague m4rg4sh (he submitted a pull request). Also there is a new version 1.8.0 - I just updated to it and everything looks great so far
Thanks for the pr. I just merged it and also update the dockerfile to 1.8.0.
I hope this pr is going to be merged into bitwarden_rs soon: https://github.com/dani-garcia/bitwarden_rs/pull/396
It would make it a lot easier for the user management. Currently registration is open to the world until you set
ENV SIGNUPS_ALLOWED=false, which only makes sense after you created a first account. After setting it you could work with invites, but the invitation model sucks (you can just invite when having an Organisation or you can do it in the admin panel, but you have to set another env variable to access it and you can't save stuff there).
So currently not really usable for the normal user. As far as I understood, with the ldap integration accounts / invites will be synced for all ldap users, which is exactly what we want. I also hope the admin panel gets some love, as in my eyes the token system to log in there isn't really easy to handle. And there seems to be a problem saving the settings you set there, but that's probably a problem in the cloudron integration.
@gml yes, the ldap invite tool would be nice. I think the best for the moment would be to slap Apache Infront of bitwarden (would be needed anyways for the websocket part) and hide the admin panel behind ldap auth (only allow admin users from within cloudron). Then invites and open registration can be disabled and admins can manually create accounts as needed.
I've now spent a bit of time to get the admin page "properly" working. Registrations are now disabled in the app itself, but users that are in the cloudron admin group can login to /admin to create the required users.
Stuff like Websockets support (for folder notifications) is still missing, as well as automatic SMTP configuration but I would say the general app is "done".
Looking forward to feedback.
Thank you for your great work! This is definitely on a good path
Some few things I noticed:
- Saving a config throws a
Error saving config: IOError. I also checked with a reboot and it seems it really can't be saved right now. (also smtp wouldn't be possible without this fixed)
- When accessing the admin panel when not logged into cloudron, you get a password prompt. A 403 HTTP would probably be more suitable and secure
And as a small Bonus: As the app is getting in a pretty good shape, it is time for a logo =D
here you go: https://github.com/bitwarden/brand/blob/master/icons/256x256.png
- Saving a config throws a
@gml thanks. I have fixed the location of the config.json created by the admin panel. Settings can now be stored (but SMTP settings should probably be done in start.sh instead). I have also added your logo.
The password prompt is actually expected since ldap auth is used in the webserver. The only way around the prompt would be to use oauth instead, but in previous attempts (the cloud torrent app) I did not get this to run.
It's working for me. A few observations:
- the invitation e-Mail did not get send as I hadn't change the SMTP settings, but once the e-Mail is on the invite list, this e-Mail can register an account
- even with 1 GB of memory assigned, I get a "ran out of memory" quite often
- currently the app is quite unresponsive as it's searching for favicons (as I can see from the logs)
- Importing from Enpass 6 (json) worked fine for me
Another question - how are updates done? Or will your app eventually become an "official" cloudron app?
even with 1 GB of memory assigned, I get a "ran out of memory" quite often
currently the app is quite unresponsive as it's searching for favicons (as I can see from the logs)
Importing from Enpass 6 (json) worked fine for me
This probably depends quite a bit on the amount of data you throw at it. I actually started with an empty vault since password history etc would not have carried over anyways. But in my case it's easy to keep a portable version of keepass around if I need a password from the old database.
Maybe the icon caching is causing some troubles for you? You could deactivate this from the settings. Probably also a good idea to get in touch with the upstream project if they are already aware on this and if there is anything to lighten the load a bit
how are updates done? Or will your app eventually become an "official" cloudron app?
My idea is to have a good base so that @nebulon can make this an official app.