Participants can't see eachother?

[jdaviescoates]

It mostly worked fine for me although for a while the other person had a bit of audio echo. I've since uninstalled it with the intention of trying the SFU version, presuming that'd work better. @MiroTalk fyi I believe Cloudron has a has a built in Turn server.

[SebGG]

is the app not using the cloudron turn server as standard?

[jdaviescoates]

@SebGG said in Participants can't see eachother?:

is the app not using the cloudron turn server as standard?

AFAIK:

SFU version: yes
P2P version: no

[nebulon]

That is correct. You can see the respective manifest addon sections at:

p2p: https://git.cloudron.io/cloudron/mirotalkp2p-app/-/blob/main/CloudronManifest.json?ref_type=heads#L14
sfu: https://git.cloudron.io/cloudron/mirotalksfu-app/-/blob/main/CloudronManifest.json?ref_type=heads#L15

[SebGG]

ok, thats waht i expected, because no connection could established when i was outside of my network. can i use the cloudron turn server ?

[nebulon]

@SebGG are you using MiroTalk SFU or p2p for a start? If you use p2p then maybe the turn server is a problem in those networks, for SFU I would expect there is some other issue then, since it would only require connection to the app itself as far as I understand, which should work if you can reach the webinterface, maybe some other browser issue then.

[SebGG]

yeah, thanks, i just tried both and saw that it is maybe a turn server issue. Now the SFU works

[nostrdev]

It appears the turn server is no longer used as an addon in SFU - could this explain why the app just does not work for many of our participants for several months now?

https://git.cloudron.io/packages/mirotalksfu-app/-/commit/05013ccfb0cbd9342433783e8ffe7c3fb14fa600

[joseph]

@nostrdev I think maybe in SFU mode, turn server is not required . It's not p2p but a central mixer . The package already sets SFU_ANNOUNCED_IP .

[avatar1024]

I can confirm there is a problem, for only for about a week or so on my end. Participant can't see each other, I can see myself but the others appear to me as turning circles who never enter the room, and everyone see the same thing (they can see themselves as if there are in the room but cannot others).

Feels like a Cloudron specific issue, unless @mirotalk-57bab571 has also seen that behaviour elsewhere?

[james]

Hello @avatar1024
Have you changed the port after the latest update? See: https://forum.cloudron.io/post/112671

[avatar1024]

@james Apologies, I missed that one entirely! It was indeed the problem.