Participants can't see eachother?

[jordanurbs]

@nebulon this is whatever is default when I install MiroTalk from the Cloudron appstore.

The cloudron is just from the digitalocean marketplace droplet, I'm not a super advanced user in any of this so I haven't manually added any firewalls or the like.

[jordanurbs]

If these pages, are any indication, it's definitely the p2p MiroTalk.

https://p2p.mirotalk.com/
https://sfu.mirotalk.com/

[girish]

@jordanurbs there are two separate apps on the app store. One for p2p and another for sfu.

[jordanurbs]

@girish not on my app store

[jdaviescoates]

@jordanurbs said in Participants can't see eachother?:

@girish not on my app store

Guessing you're not on 7.7 yet (me neither, but may upgrade now so I can play), that has stuff added that made adding the SFU app possible.

[jordanurbs]

@jdaviescoates interesting, I just installed this fresh yesterday from DO. Perhaps they haven't updated the marketplace image yet...

[girish]

Yes, correct. Updating DO marketplace image will take a while . Only after 7.7 is stable.

[jordanurbs]

Update: upgraded to 7.7 and yes, now I see both.

SFU works fine, as far as I can tell.

Still no luck with p2p

[girish]

That's probably expected. p2p doesn't work in all cases, this is why the sfu mode exists.

[avatar1024]

I also have this issue with the p2p version. Participants cannot see each other.

[MiroTalk]

Anyone noticed a similar behavior in our official Mirotalk-P2P live demo at https://p2p.mirotalk.com?

It's possible that the issue stems from incorrect Turn server configuration. The Turn demo server specified in our repo .env file has a traffic limit of 50GB per month, which have already been exceeded. Remember to install your own TURN server using the documentation available here.

For more information on Stun/Turn servers, you can refer to our documentation here

[jdaviescoates]

It mostly worked fine for me although for a while the other person had a bit of audio echo. I've since uninstalled it with the intention of trying the SFU version, presuming that'd work better. @MiroTalk fyi I believe Cloudron has a has a built in Turn server.

[SebGG]

is the app not using the cloudron turn server as standard?

[jdaviescoates]

@SebGG said in Participants can't see eachother?:

is the app not using the cloudron turn server as standard?

AFAIK:

SFU version: yes
P2P version: no

[nebulon]

That is correct. You can see the respective manifest addon sections at:

p2p: https://git.cloudron.io/cloudron/mirotalkp2p-app/-/blob/main/CloudronManifest.json?ref_type=heads#L14
sfu: https://git.cloudron.io/cloudron/mirotalksfu-app/-/blob/main/CloudronManifest.json?ref_type=heads#L15

[SebGG]

ok, thats waht i expected, because no connection could established when i was outside of my network. can i use the cloudron turn server ?

[nebulon]

@SebGG are you using MiroTalk SFU or p2p for a start? If you use p2p then maybe the turn server is a problem in those networks, for SFU I would expect there is some other issue then, since it would only require connection to the app itself as far as I understand, which should work if you can reach the webinterface, maybe some other browser issue then.

[SebGG]

yeah, thanks, i just tried both and saw that it is maybe a turn server issue. Now the SFU works