NTFY app overview always says "connecting..."

[girish]

@lukas said in I'm getting desperate:

Both apps have each created a theme URL, but in the NTFY app overview I always see a "connecting..."

are you referring to the Android/iOS app here?

[lukas]

@girish said in I'm getting desperate:

are you referring to the Android/iOS app here?

Android

[girish]

I just tried this and it seems to work fine.

I installed ntfy in our demo - https://my.demo.cloudron.io/#/apps .

You can add it in android - https://notify.demo.cloudron.io/ . username and password is admin and supersecret . Subscribe to a channel called alerts .

curl -H 'Authorization: Bearer tk_fhu5igz2tbj01nd49xyryksmdr9th' -d "Hi" https://notify.demo.cloudron.io/alerts from your laptop will also show alerts on mobile app.

[lukas]

Reinstalled NTFY, added your "demo" server with your mentioned credentials and set Element Messenger to NTFY notification. Sent me some test messages from other smartphone and no notification received. Here you can see a screenshot:

verbinde... means "connecting..." and here the log output from NTFY: https://nopaste.net/eMel6cf0U2

NTFY is running in a docker container on Cloudron, correct?

Btw.: I switched in Element App to NextPush and this works fine.

Thank and regards
Lukas

[girish]

@lukas I think there is a bug upstream - https://github.com/element-hq/element-android/issues/7069 .

Curiously, my android element has no feature called UnifiedPush. Maybe because I installed from Google Play and the only notification method available is Google Services. Did you install from f-droid?

[lukas]

@girish said in NTFY app overview always says "connecting...":

Did you install from f-droid?

Yes

[girish]

@lukas said in NTFY app overview always says "connecting...":

Reinstalled NTFY, added your "demo" server with your mentioned credentials and set Element Messenger to NTFY notification

How do you do this btw? We cannot find this setting even a f-droid installation.

[lukas]

@girish said in NTFY app overview always says "connecting...":

How do you do this btw? We cannot find this setting even a f-droid installation.

In notification settings

[girish]

@lukas thank you. your screenshot made me realize the obvious. I guess we have to install the apps to have the notification services show up. I had uninstalled ntfy app after testing.

[girish]

@lukas yeah, looks to be some integration issue with element+ntfy. I can't get it to send anything either. Websocket configuration appears correct in the ntfy package. I have verified that part.

[lukas]

@girish said in NTFY app overview always says "connecting...":

yeah, looks to be some integration issue with element+ntfy

OK, how we can continue with this issue ?

[girish]

@lukas I think https://github.com/element-hq/element-android/issues/7069 is the issue, no? Otherwise, I think you have to open a new issue there. ntfy and element both work independently fine just not together.

[lukas]

@girish said in NTFY app overview always says "connecting...":

I think https://github.com/element-hq/element-android/issues/7069 is the issue, no?

Yes, looks like my issue. I will comment it, ty

[lukas]

@girish got this answer in GitHub:
https://github.com/element-hq/element-android/issues/7069#issuecomment-2090440793

[lukas]

Just FYI, this helped me a lot to get it running and to understand how it works: https://github.com/element-hq/element-android/issues/7069#issuecomment-2109439991

[andreasdueren]

@lukas said in NTFY app overview always says "connecting...":

Btw.: I switched in Element App to NextPush and this works fine.

With me it's actually the other way around. I've been using ntfy for Element Push but I'd like to install NextPush for Nextcloud talk notifications but can't get it to work. I'm sure it's some trivial thing that's missing but I can't find any proper documentation on setting it up. Would you mind sharing the steps you took?

I have installed the App on the NC-Level and on my mobile device. Logged in on my device, it shows up in the backend of the NC-Level App but won't display notifications.