Matrix Federation not working - curl works but Federation Tester doesn't

jdaviescoates

had never checked previously, but same:

Looks like perhaps we need to add some DNS records that it isn't finding

Here is the json report

{
  "WellKnownResult": {
    "m.server": "",
    "result": "No .well-known found",
    "CacheExpiresAt": 0
  },
  "DNSResult": {
    "SRVSkipped": false,
    "SRVCName": "",
    "SRVRecords": null,
    "SRVError": {
      "Message": "lookup _matrix._tcp.chat.uniteddiversity.coop on 8.8.8.8:53: no such host"
    },
    "Hosts": {
      "chat.uniteddiversity.coop": {
        "CName": "chat.uniteddiversity.coop.",
        "Addrs": [
          "89.58.52.168"
        ],
        "Error": null
      }
    },
    "Addrs": [
      "89.58.52.168:8448"
    ]
  },
  "ConnectionReports": {},
  "ConnectionErrors": {
    "89.58.52.168:8448": {
      "Message": "Get \"https://89.58.52.168:8448/_matrix/key/v2/server\": context deadline exceeded (Client.Timeout exceeded while awaiting headers)"
    }
  },
  "Version": {
    "error": "Get \"matrix://chat.uniteddiversity.coop/_matrix/federation/v1/version\": dial tcp 89.58.52.168:8448: i/o timeout"
  },
  "FederationOK": false
}

I'm on my phone but I think that gives some clues as to what needs adding.

Hopefully @staff can update the package to automate adding the necessary entries needed to make this work.

jdaviescoates

This is what I get when testing matrix.org

{
  "WellKnownResult": {
    "m.server": "matrix-federation.matrix.org:443",
    "CacheExpiresAt": 1672707841
  },
  "DNSResult": {
    "SRVSkipped": true,
    "SRVCName": "",
    "SRVRecords": null,
    "SRVError": null,
    "Hosts": {
      "matrix-federation.matrix.org": {
        "CName": "matrix-federation.matrix.org.",
        "Addrs": [
          "2606:4700:10::ac43:135a",
          "2606:4700:10::6814:c825",
          "2606:4700:10::6814:c925",
          "104.20.200.37",
          "172.67.19.90",
          "104.20.201.37"
        ],
        "Error": null
      }
    },
    "Addrs": [
      "[2606:4700:10::ac43:135a]:443",
      "[2606:4700:10::6814:c825]:443",
      "[2606:4700:10::6814:c925]:443",
      "104.20.200.37:443",
      "172.67.19.90:443",
      "104.20.201.37:443"
    ]
  },
  "ConnectionReports": {
    "104.20.200.37:443": {
      "Certificates": [
        {
          "SubjectCommonName": "sni.cloudflaressl.com",
          "IssuerCommonName": "Cloudflare Inc ECC CA-3",
          "SHA256Fingerprint": "kBX1oyhKwmIT6Tm+cwaR+UvttEmkpHypQcUTPHWrJqU",
          "DNSNames": [
            "matrix.org",
            "*.matrix.org",
            "sni.cloudflaressl.com"
          ]
        },
        {
          "SubjectCommonName": "Cloudflare Inc ECC CA-3",
          "IssuerCommonName": "Baltimore CyberTrust Root",
          "SHA256Fingerprint": "OrvmPa91bFAWtrhfUgFf2Oisvid8UIexJ6YFY6hB7Yo",
          "DNSNames": null
        }
      ],
      "Cipher": {
        "Version": "TLS 1.3",
        "CipherSuite": "TLS_AES_128_GCM_SHA256"
      },
      "Checks": {
        "AllChecksOK": true,
        "MatchingServerName": true,
        "FutureValidUntilTS": true,
        "HasEd25519Key": true,
        "AllEd25519ChecksOK": true,
        "Ed25519Checks": {
          "ed25519:a_RXGa": {
            "ValidEd25519": true,
            "MatchingSignature": true
          }
        },
        "ValidCertificates": true
      },
      "Errors": [],
      "Ed25519VerifyKeys": {
        "ed25519:a_RXGa": "l8Hft5qXKn1vfHrg3p4+W8gELQVo8N13JkluMfmn2sQ"
      },
      "Info": {},
      "Keys": {
        "old_verify_keys": {
          "ed25519:auto": {
            "expired_ts": 1576767829750,
            "key": "Noi6WqcDj0QmPxCNQqgezwTlBKrfqehY1u2FyWP9uYw"
          }
        },
        "server_name": "matrix.org",
        "signatures": {
          "matrix.org": {
            "ed25519:a_RXGa": "+/oYcZdYctgxcZCCrP4wx5S3rc1+2pbdpv3sJkKBpqn/uhJd+7+NPd9hUb3HBw+CVjjGugNSznM3RUgri4kQAQ"
          }
        },
        "valid_until_ts": 1672751664505,
        "verify_keys": {
          "ed25519:a_RXGa": {
            "key": "l8Hft5qXKn1vfHrg3p4+W8gELQVo8N13JkluMfmn2sQ"
          }
        }
      }
    },
    "104.20.201.37:443": {
      "Certificates": [
        {
          "SubjectCommonName": "sni.cloudflaressl.com",
          "IssuerCommonName": "Cloudflare Inc ECC CA-3",
          "SHA256Fingerprint": "kBX1oyhKwmIT6Tm+cwaR+UvttEmkpHypQcUTPHWrJqU",
          "DNSNames": [
            "matrix.org",
            "*.matrix.org",
            "sni.cloudflaressl.com"
          ]
        },
        {
          "SubjectCommonName": "Cloudflare Inc ECC CA-3",
          "IssuerCommonName": "Baltimore CyberTrust Root",
          "SHA256Fingerprint": "OrvmPa91bFAWtrhfUgFf2Oisvid8UIexJ6YFY6hB7Yo",
          "DNSNames": null
        }
      ],
      "Cipher": {
        "Version": "TLS 1.3",
        "CipherSuite": "TLS_AES_128_GCM_SHA256"
      },
      "Checks": {
        "AllChecksOK": true,
        "MatchingServerName": true,
        "FutureValidUntilTS": true,
        "HasEd25519Key": true,
        "AllEd25519ChecksOK": true,
        "Ed25519Checks": {
          "ed25519:a_RXGa": {
            "ValidEd25519": true,
            "MatchingSignature": true
          }
        },
        "ValidCertificates": true
      },
      "Errors": [],
      "Ed25519VerifyKeys": {
        "ed25519:a_RXGa": "l8Hft5qXKn1vfHrg3p4+W8gELQVo8N13JkluMfmn2sQ"
      },
      "Info": {},
      "Keys": {
        "old_verify_keys": {
          "ed25519:auto": {
            "expired_ts": 1576767829750,
            "key": "Noi6WqcDj0QmPxCNQqgezwTlBKrfqehY1u2FyWP9uYw"
          }
        },
        "server_name": "matrix.org",
        "signatures": {
          "matrix.org": {
            "ed25519:a_RXGa": "+/oYcZdYctgxcZCCrP4wx5S3rc1+2pbdpv3sJkKBpqn/uhJd+7+NPd9hUb3HBw+CVjjGugNSznM3RUgri4kQAQ"
          }
        },
        "valid_until_ts": 1672751664505,
        "verify_keys": {
          "ed25519:a_RXGa": {
            "key": "l8Hft5qXKn1vfHrg3p4+W8gELQVo8N13JkluMfmn2sQ"
          }
        }
      }
    },
    "172.67.19.90:443": {
      "Certificates": [
        {
          "SubjectCommonName": "sni.cloudflaressl.com",
          "IssuerCommonName": "Cloudflare Inc ECC CA-3",
          "SHA256Fingerprint": "kBX1oyhKwmIT6Tm+cwaR+UvttEmkpHypQcUTPHWrJqU",
          "DNSNames": [
            "matrix.org",
            "*.matrix.org",
            "sni.cloudflaressl.com"
          ]
        },
        {
          "SubjectCommonName": "Cloudflare Inc ECC CA-3",
          "IssuerCommonName": "Baltimore CyberTrust Root",
          "SHA256Fingerprint": "OrvmPa91bFAWtrhfUgFf2Oisvid8UIexJ6YFY6hB7Yo",
          "DNSNames": null
        }
      ],
      "Cipher": {
        "Version": "TLS 1.3",
        "CipherSuite": "TLS_AES_128_GCM_SHA256"
      },
      "Checks": {
        "AllChecksOK": true,
        "MatchingServerName": true,
        "FutureValidUntilTS": true,
        "HasEd25519Key": true,
        "AllEd25519ChecksOK": true,
        "Ed25519Checks": {
          "ed25519:a_RXGa": {
            "ValidEd25519": true,
            "MatchingSignature": true
          }
        },
        "ValidCertificates": true
      },
      "Errors": [],
      "Ed25519VerifyKeys": {
        "ed25519:a_RXGa": "l8Hft5qXKn1vfHrg3p4+W8gELQVo8N13JkluMfmn2sQ"
      },
      "Info": {},
      "Keys": {
        "old_verify_keys": {
          "ed25519:auto": {
            "expired_ts": 1576767829750,
            "key": "Noi6WqcDj0QmPxCNQqgezwTlBKrfqehY1u2FyWP9uYw"
          }
        },
        "server_name": "matrix.org",
        "signatures": {
          "matrix.org": {
            "ed25519:a_RXGa": "+/oYcZdYctgxcZCCrP4wx5S3rc1+2pbdpv3sJkKBpqn/uhJd+7+NPd9hUb3HBw+CVjjGugNSznM3RUgri4kQAQ"
          }
        },
        "valid_until_ts": 1672751664505,
        "verify_keys": {
          "ed25519:a_RXGa": {
            "key": "l8Hft5qXKn1vfHrg3p4+W8gELQVo8N13JkluMfmn2sQ"
          }
        }
      }
    },
    "[2606:4700:10::6814:c825]:443": {
      "Certificates": [
        {
          "SubjectCommonName": "sni.cloudflaressl.com",
          "IssuerCommonName": "Cloudflare Inc ECC CA-3",
          "SHA256Fingerprint": "kBX1oyhKwmIT6Tm+cwaR+UvttEmkpHypQcUTPHWrJqU",
          "DNSNames": [
            "matrix.org",
            "*.matrix.org",
            "sni.cloudflaressl.com"
          ]
        },
        {
          "SubjectCommonName": "Cloudflare Inc ECC CA-3",
          "IssuerCommonName": "Baltimore CyberTrust Root",
          "SHA256Fingerprint": "OrvmPa91bFAWtrhfUgFf2Oisvid8UIexJ6YFY6hB7Yo",
          "DNSNames": null
        }
      ],
      "Cipher": {
        "Version": "TLS 1.3",
        "CipherSuite": "TLS_AES_128_GCM_SHA256"
      },
      "Checks": {
        "AllChecksOK": true,
        "MatchingServerName": true,
        "FutureValidUntilTS": true,
        "HasEd25519Key": true,
        "AllEd25519ChecksOK": true,
        "Ed25519Checks": {
          "ed25519:a_RXGa": {
            "ValidEd25519": true,
            "MatchingSignature": true
          }
        },
        "ValidCertificates": true
      },
      "Errors": [],
      "Ed25519VerifyKeys": {
        "ed25519:a_RXGa": "l8Hft5qXKn1vfHrg3p4+W8gELQVo8N13JkluMfmn2sQ"
      },
      "Info": {},
      "Keys": {
        "old_verify_keys": {
          "ed25519:auto": {
            "expired_ts": 1576767829750,
            "key": "Noi6WqcDj0QmPxCNQqgezwTlBKrfqehY1u2FyWP9uYw"
          }
        },
        "server_name": "matrix.org",
        "signatures": {
          "matrix.org": {
            "ed25519:a_RXGa": "+/oYcZdYctgxcZCCrP4wx5S3rc1+2pbdpv3sJkKBpqn/uhJd+7+NPd9hUb3HBw+CVjjGugNSznM3RUgri4kQAQ"
          }
        },
        "valid_until_ts": 1672751664505,
        "verify_keys": {
          "ed25519:a_RXGa": {
            "key": "l8Hft5qXKn1vfHrg3p4+W8gELQVo8N13JkluMfmn2sQ"
          }
        }
      }
    },
    "[2606:4700:10::6814:c925]:443": {
      "Certificates": [
        {
          "SubjectCommonName": "sni.cloudflaressl.com",
          "IssuerCommonName": "Cloudflare Inc ECC CA-3",
          "SHA256Fingerprint": "kBX1oyhKwmIT6Tm+cwaR+UvttEmkpHypQcUTPHWrJqU",
          "DNSNames": [
            "matrix.org",
            "*.matrix.org",
            "sni.cloudflaressl.com"
          ]
        },
        {
          "SubjectCommonName": "Cloudflare Inc ECC CA-3",
          "IssuerCommonName": "Baltimore CyberTrust Root",
          "SHA256Fingerprint": "OrvmPa91bFAWtrhfUgFf2Oisvid8UIexJ6YFY6hB7Yo",
          "DNSNames": null
        }
      ],
      "Cipher": {
        "Version": "TLS 1.3",
        "CipherSuite": "TLS_AES_128_GCM_SHA256"
      },
      "Checks": {
        "AllChecksOK": true,
        "MatchingServerName": true,
        "FutureValidUntilTS": true,
        "HasEd25519Key": true,
        "AllEd25519ChecksOK": true,
        "Ed25519Checks": {
          "ed25519:a_RXGa": {
            "ValidEd25519": true,
            "MatchingSignature": true
          }
        },
        "ValidCertificates": true
      },
      "Errors": [],
      "Ed25519VerifyKeys": {
        "ed25519:a_RXGa": "l8Hft5qXKn1vfHrg3p4+W8gELQVo8N13JkluMfmn2sQ"
      },
      "Info": {},
      "Keys": {
        "old_verify_keys": {
          "ed25519:auto": {
            "expired_ts": 1576767829750,
            "key": "Noi6WqcDj0QmPxCNQqgezwTlBKrfqehY1u2FyWP9uYw"
          }
        },
        "server_name": "matrix.org",
        "signatures": {
          "matrix.org": {
            "ed25519:a_RXGa": "+/oYcZdYctgxcZCCrP4wx5S3rc1+2pbdpv3sJkKBpqn/uhJd+7+NPd9hUb3HBw+CVjjGugNSznM3RUgri4kQAQ"
          }
        },
        "valid_until_ts": 1672751664505,
        "verify_keys": {
          "ed25519:a_RXGa": {
            "key": "l8Hft5qXKn1vfHrg3p4+W8gELQVo8N13JkluMfmn2sQ"
          }
        }
      }
    },
    "[2606:4700:10::ac43:135a]:443": {
      "Certificates": [
        {
          "SubjectCommonName": "sni.cloudflaressl.com",
          "IssuerCommonName": "Cloudflare Inc ECC CA-3",
          "SHA256Fingerprint": "kBX1oyhKwmIT6Tm+cwaR+UvttEmkpHypQcUTPHWrJqU",
          "DNSNames": [
            "matrix.org",
            "*.matrix.org",
            "sni.cloudflaressl.com"
          ]
        },
        {
          "SubjectCommonName": "Cloudflare Inc ECC CA-3",
          "IssuerCommonName": "Baltimore CyberTrust Root",
          "SHA256Fingerprint": "OrvmPa91bFAWtrhfUgFf2Oisvid8UIexJ6YFY6hB7Yo",
          "DNSNames": null
        }
      ],
      "Cipher": {
        "Version": "TLS 1.3",
        "CipherSuite": "TLS_AES_128_GCM_SHA256"
      },
      "Checks": {
        "AllChecksOK": true,
        "MatchingServerName": true,
        "FutureValidUntilTS": true,
        "HasEd25519Key": true,
        "AllEd25519ChecksOK": true,
        "Ed25519Checks": {
          "ed25519:a_RXGa": {
            "ValidEd25519": true,
            "MatchingSignature": true
          }
        },
        "ValidCertificates": true
      },
      "Errors": [],
      "Ed25519VerifyKeys": {
        "ed25519:a_RXGa": "l8Hft5qXKn1vfHrg3p4+W8gELQVo8N13JkluMfmn2sQ"
      },
      "Info": {},
      "Keys": {
        "old_verify_keys": {
          "ed25519:auto": {
            "expired_ts": 1576767829750,
            "key": "Noi6WqcDj0QmPxCNQqgezwTlBKrfqehY1u2FyWP9uYw"
          }
        },
        "server_name": "matrix.org",
        "signatures": {
          "matrix.org": {
            "ed25519:a_RXGa": "+/oYcZdYctgxcZCCrP4wx5S3rc1+2pbdpv3sJkKBpqn/uhJd+7+NPd9hUb3HBw+CVjjGugNSznM3RUgri4kQAQ"
          }
        },
        "valid_until_ts": 1672751664505,
        "verify_keys": {
          "ed25519:a_RXGa": {
            "key": "l8Hft5qXKn1vfHrg3p4+W8gELQVo8N13JkluMfmn2sQ"
          }
        }
      }
    }
  },
  "ConnectionErrors": {},
  "Version": {
    "name": "Synapse",
    "version": "1.74.0 (b=matrix-org-hotfixes,5a1b56b9b0)"
  },
  "FederationOK": true
}

jdaviescoates

Seems for some reason on Cloudron it's not picking up the well known and port. Odd

murgero

@Supaiku You have to use the matrix federated domain NOT the app domain (unless these are both the same, by default on cloudron they are NOT)

Example, my matrix server is matrix.urgero.org with urgero.org being the user's domain for federation.

Testing matrix.urgero.org actually fails with that tool - but urgero.org does not.

Hope this helps.

Edit: @jdaviescoates

murgero

@jdaviescoates said in Matrix Federation not working - curl works but Federation Tester doesn't:

uniteddiversity.coop

jdaviescoates

@murgero thanks!

So looks like everything is actually working fine

murgero

@jdaviescoates The tool says your matrix install is working perfectly lol

jdaviescoates

@murgero yep! presumably the same for OP @Supaiku domain too?

murgero

@jdaviescoates I'd imagine it would be so.

Supaiku

@murgero ah yes... this does seem to be the trick.

I just found the line in the docs that says:

Step 3. Federation

Federation setup is automatic. Use the Federation Tester to verify that everything is setup properly. Note you must enter the server_name (like example.com) in the form field in the website and NOT the location of your home server (despite what the form says).

Cloudron makes it easy to run web apps like WordPress, Nextcloud, GitLab on your server. Find out more or install now.

Cloudron Forum

Matrix Federation not working - curl works but Federation Tester doesn't