Configuring SMTP Mail notifier for Statping

chris

thanks @brutalbirdie for the "teach a man to fish" breakdown of how best to troubleshoot the app add ons and terminal look up for variables.

I found it helpful. and was able to see the apps SMTP info - HOWEVER, with that info, i was not able to get a successful email out of the app via its SMTP Mail notifier. i tried both ports with and without TLS/SSL.

as of now i have two primary issues when using statping on cloudron

emails do not appear to be going out
because i am not getting emails, i cant validate a new users email, which means i cant add new users to get notifications.

Here is the error code (ip masked)
{ "Op": "dial", "Net": "tcp", "Source": null, "Addr": { "IP": "xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx", "Port": 2465, "Zone": "" }, "Err": { "Syscall": "connect", "Err": 111 } }

BrutalBirdie

@chris please open a new topic about this issue and link this topic to it. (and also me if you wish so)
This way different problems stay separated and also their solutions which makes the solution easier to find in the future.

BrutalBirdie

Oh I guess this got moved, good to know

The error code is from the Cloudron Mail tab or from the Statping app?

chris

@brutalbirdie error is from statping backend when adding (and testing) smtp info:
image (3).jpg

girish

@chris looks to be some bug in the app. Unfortunately, there are many issues with the app and others have also requested that this app be marked as unstable (https://forum.cloudron.io/topic/4106/mark-this-app-as-unstable/). To add to it, the upstream author is not responding much either about bug reports we raised.

So, I don't have a good answer other than to not use this app for the moment until we find some time to fix the issues. I am looking into publishing phpservermonitor in the next few days (since @msbt has already packaged it).

chris

@girish i got SMTP working when used with SENDGRID, no problem - so i am not sure this particular issue is a bug with the app (seems not).

Maybe my SMTP settings from cloudron are the issue, any other ideas?

girish

@chris Oh, I just noticed that the SMTP Host is not correct. It should be mail and not my.domain.com. This is because the port 2465 is only exposed internally and not exposed externally.

Can you try these and let me know what works (same username and password as above):

SMTP Host: mail and Port 2465
SMTP Host: mail and Port 2525
SMTP Host: my.xx.net and Port 587 <-- I expect this to definitely work since you say sendgrid worked

BTW, Where did you get the SMTP Username and Password from? Did you just create a mailbox (if so, that is the correct way) or from the environment variables (this is also correct).

chris

@girish i followed @BrutalBirdie notes from this forum post

running printenv from within terminal to see user/pass/port info. let me try your suggested edits now...

chris

@girish no luck with any of those 3 approaches. all failed with the app, reverted back to send grid for now.

girish

@chris thanks for testing. I found the reason why it won't connect to port 587. It's because when a connection is "internal", Cloudron won't offer STARTTLS. This makes Go reject the connection as unencrypted. This is the reason why we had made port 2465 in the first place but that doesn't work for some reason. Debugging...

chris

@girish thanks for looking deeper into this, hopefully the fix is easy.

while testing various SMTP out configs, i also thought i would integrate twilio, i already have twilio accounts, so putting in the Account SID and Token was easy, and worked, but when i put the phone number in and saved, i got an error, status code 422. will open new forum post on this one to keep this one related to SMTP.

girish

OK, decided to look into this to see if it's something obvious.

The testing logic is here https://github.com/statping/statping/blob/1a56afe7f76403ad8f839a45de02b2715370eb6c/notifiers/email.go#L137 which in turn just calls into https://github.com/statping/statping/blob/1a56afe7f76403ad8f839a45de02b2715370eb6c/notifiers/email.go#L155 . By my reading, SSL will be set to false (ApiKey is curious use of some random db field it seems). Which then lands in an unmaintained go module - https://github.com/go-mail/mail/blob/v2/smtp.go . The default for StartTLS in the package is opportunistic - https://github.com/go-mail/mail/blob/v2/smtp.go#L163 , so it should all just work but clearly doesn't

chris

Thanks for taking another look into this @girish - the maintainer seems unwilling/unable to address the issue you raised on github. For now using a third party SMTP is working fine with this app (sendgrid) but i would love if this apps twilio support (SMS) support, worked... as its tands i cant get that working either. in any case, looking into the new app on cloudron you just added: https://forum.cloudron.io/category/126/php-server-monitor as it providers similar features.

girish

After much Go code spelunking:

I guess a fix has to be made to statping but generally I prefer changing the platform to adapt to the app unless it's an outright bug. So, I am going to see if I can fix our mail server.

Notes to future me:

statping always sets mailer.SSL to fase. This means port 2465 can never work
Ultimately, go-mail in turn uses net/smtp which won't send passwords with TLS

Cloudron makes it easy to run web apps like WordPress, Nextcloud, GitLab on your server. Find out more or install now.

Configuring SMTP Mail notifier for Statping