Cloudron 9.0 (beta) bug reports

[girish]

@Kubernetes it's part of the App Store now. We forgot to enable it, it's enabled now.

[robi]

@girish that would explain it

[msbt]

Chiming in here since I just tested the 9.0.0 setup and ran into some issues (maybe you fixed them already, didn't check):

• After setting up the user and getting forwarded to the dashboard, I got the message "Removing containers for upgrade" at the top which never disappeared and docker didn't start properly. At some point I did a service box restart which seems to have fixed it, all service came back on after that which they didn't before.

• stats aren't working, box.log is getting spammed with

box:cron TypeError: Cannot read properties of undefined (reading 'trim')
    at readDiskMetrics (/home/yellowtent/box/src/metrics.js:117:29)
    at async readSystemMetrics (/home/yellowtent/box/src/metrics.js:154:25)
    at async Object.sendToGraphite (/home/yellowtent/box/src/metrics.js:164:20)

• /#/metrics hovering on the apps in disk usage changes width of the container, not really a problem, but doesn't look great

• /#/users I've added a bunch of users and only 10 are visible, the container has a max-height of 400px and adds scrollbars, even though there's plenty of vertical space available. Also not a problem, but not great ux

• /#/backup-sites the admin-users seems to be able to add backups ("add"-button is visible even though it shouldn't be), when clicking next, I get a 403 error with

body: Object { status: "Forbidden", message: "role 'owner' is required but user has only 'admin'" }

• /#/backup-sites when adding a MinIO destination as admin, prefix is mandatory ("prefix must be a string"), that wasn't the case until now I believe

There were a few more errors which I could't reproduce, so leaving them out for now.

Other than that, great work on everything!

[girish]

@msbt said in Cloudron 9.0 (beta) bug reports:

Awesome, thanks for testing. We will be putting out 9.0.1 shortly (will confirm here).

I tried reproducing the set up issue but haven't managed to so far.

The disk graph issue is already logged in https://git.cloudron.io/platform/box/-/issues/855

Rest of the issues are valid, and we have fixed it now.

Let us know as you find more!

[d19dotca]

Just use the demo Cloudron and love the UI updates, a nice refresh for sure! Kudos, and great job as always! I'm always proud of the work you guys do, and I hope you are as well.

With that said, I did want to offer some feedback (not bugs per-se but more feedback that I saw in a quick explore of the demo):

1. The Spam Filtering box seems like it wasn't touched in the UI. I think it should be much larger (and the number of lines in each box should also be much larger, perhaps adapting dynamically to the viewport height), as right now it's sort of just a small window/pop-up in the upper left corner of the boxed page width.

2. Same as #1 but for the pop-ups for IPv4 and IPv6 provider configurations. This actually seems to go for many of the pop-ups/overlays.

3. The Services page memory usage column could probably use a bit of a start/end visual indicator, so that it's easy at a glance to see what is close to filling up. Maybe it's something I'll get used to, but since it's a percentage and visual for it, I'd normally anticipate having some sort of start & end lines so the percentage is much more visibly apparent in the bar part. Hopefully that makes sense, I may not be explaining that well.

4. If there is only one disk recognized, maybe make this full-width for the content box rather than only 50% of the width? Otherwise it feels unnecessarily cramped. Actually on second thought, maybe this one doesn't make sense, because then there may be too large a gap between the App name and Size columns which wouldn't be easy to follow unless each row was a different soft alternating background colour for example. So maybe it's fine the way it is?

5. The mailboxes list feels like it should be clickable rather than needing to click the three-dot menu to the right side. This would make it behave much like the mail domains page where the full domain is clickable. Right now the difference in those two pages feels a bit disjointed in behaviour. Same goes for the Users page and Domains page as well. Either that, or make the domains under Mail behave the same as all the other ones for consistency.

[Neiluj]

Hi there - thanks for the great work on v9.
For the little I played with, it looks and feels great so far.

From the demo server, I will pinch in with a couple of questions/comments too:

• 1 - Branding - Footer: This seems to be available only from the login page and not from the dashboard anymore. is this intended?

In v8, we store some references and links to internal help documentation etc in the footer. So I wonder if/what could replace this in v9?

• 2 - The help menu:
  • Is this something visible to all users? No it is not, tried and saw.
  • Related to the point above, instead of the footer, potentially, I would love the opportunity to have such an help menu option for non-admin users, so long as the content is editable / amendable by admin. I hope that I make sense

• 3 - Log out - This is for sure a matter of tastes and colour etc.. but since I got confused initially: working on a fairly big screen I looked for the logout button for longer than I believe I should. Instinctively (or maybe from previous version) I was looking for it below the username as I clicked on it.
  Then I noticed it on the profile page.
  Maybe it is only me, but should it remain there, then I would suggest potentially a change of colour, to something that pops up a little bit more.

• 4 - Menu item for user with User Manager priviledges (possibly this is not tied to v9 entirely)
  At the moment, a user with a user manager role see the following menu items

Clicking on the LDAP/OpenID/Settings option open the "My Apps" page.
While I think it is right that the User Manager does not have access to these options, I think that the options should simply not be visible, rather that to open another / different page. This is likely to create confusion.

I hope that it makes sense.
Speaking personally, v9 gives already a very nice feeling.
This is it for now and my short play around - I might pop back in later on with more.
Many thanks for all the work and support in the background!

[Bedrijfstak14]

Hi there,

Cloudron v9 is amazing, and I really like the new interface.

However, I believe I have found a bug. I have created a test instance on AWS. When I add a domain for which the DNS is on Cloudflare, I cannot enable the proxying option (see error).
When I uncheck the "enable proxying" box, the domain gets added. I have tested this with multiple domains, but the result is the same.

[james]

Hello @d19dotca, @Neiluj and @Bedrijfstak14 - thank you for the detailed feedback.

Firstly, I am no web designer by any means, so all my opinions can be discarded if you have a better idea.
And please, share your ideas.

---

@d19dotca

1. and 2. good point!
3. I can second your opinion. Maybe we should give the bar a visible border in the same blue color? Suggestions on styling are very welcome
4. Understand where you're coming from, like spreadsheets where you alternate between white and gray to faster separate each row.
There are many options to make tables more readable.
In my opinion to not clash with the aesthetic of the otherwise clean UI, maybe a visual cue based on hover over might be a good idea?
But the hover over might not be the best for mobile view then.
5. good point

---

@Neiluj

1. I see, you are missing the footer in the dashboard. Maybe this should be re-added. I know some Cloudron hosters that put Need Help? there with a link to their internal support chat. Ah, reading further after your screenshot, you do the same.
2. Nice suggestion this might indeed be a good replacement for the old footer
3. good to think about it
4. good catch, should only be visible if the permission level matches

---

@Bedrijfstak14

Thanks for the report, we are looking into it.

[girish]

@Bedrijfstak14 thanks , that one was already fixed in 9.0.1 - https://git.cloudron.io/platform/box/-/commit/e9318d7f11e1198ab988825fed31b0f42e262718

[joseph]

@d19dotca said in Cloudron 9.0 (beta) bug reports:

The mailboxes list feels like it should be clickable

For all the table views, the idea is to have some sort of "favorite"/"common action" buttons to the left of the "..." . And also some default action . We will have this for 9.1 most likely.

[girish]

@Neiluj said in Cloudron 9.0 (beta) bug reports:

While I think it is right that the User Manager does not have access to these options, I think that the options should simply not be visible, rather that to open another / different page. This is likely to create confusion.

Whoops, that's a bug. They should not appear at all indeed, fixed now. User Manager role just has ability to add/remove users and groups and that's about it.

[msbt]

Just updated to 9.0.1, /#/server still doesn't show stats and the trim error got replaced with this one, which is odd, because the disk stats are actually working when clicking on the "Details" button, but the rest of the graphs aren't:

box:metrics BoxError: Could not get disk stats
    at readDiskMetrics (/home/yellowtent/box/src/metrics.js:115:27)
    at async readSystemMetrics (/home/yellowtent/box/src/metrics.js:154:25)
    at async pipeSystemToMap (/home/yellowtent/box/src/metrics.js:425:21)

Browser console says this "Uncaught TypeError: can't access property "blockReadTotal", metric is undefined"

[girish]

@msbt I fixed that issue earlier today morning - https://git.cloudron.io/platform/box/-/commit/41c00eda7468ee27ff5250bdf74f672684b738cc . Should have a 9.0.2 later today .

[andreasdueren]

I'd suggest improving contrast on the app store cards for better visibility. Something like this with stronger highlight on hover.

[Lanhild]

Not a bug per-se, but I believe it would be better to replace this Alert icon by another one, as this makes the user believe there is an error, rather than outstanding tasks to do

[Lanhild]

The application grid container should be vertically aligned with the toolbar header

Currently, there's a visible gutter when resizing the window to a smaller size.

[Lanhild]

Add an autocomplete=off attribute where deemed necessary, e.g the user creation modal email, username, and password recovery inputs.

[Lanhild]

The message makes it as if there is no form validation before authenticating the request. If this is the case, might want to check in on that.

[Lanhild]

Apart from the cursor style, there is no visual cue that the app domain is a link.

[Lanhild]

Email configuration changes can be saved, even if there were no changes. The button should be disabled if the value hasn't changed.