Standard package formats
-
Has there been discussion about adopting a packaging format standard rather than a Cloudron specific one?
The one that’s probably closest is the Cloud Native Buildpacks from CNCF https://buildpacks.io/
Why? It means a wider universe of apps that could be ready to go. More information and education on the format.
-
@robi said in Standard package formats:
Perhaps you need to see the BayLISA talks about the origins and architecture of Cloudron.
-
Has there been discussion about adopting a packaging format standard rather than a Cloudron specific one?
The one that’s probably closest is the Cloud Native Buildpacks from CNCF https://buildpacks.io/
Why? It means a wider universe of apps that could be ready to go. More information and education on the format.
@bmann said in Standard package formats:
The website says that buildpacks has "been adopted by Cloud Foundry and other PaaS such as Google App Engine, Gitlab, Knative, Deis, Dokku, and Drie." Do I take this to mean that I can take any apps's buildpack, say from Heroku (or from any of those listed), and just run it in any of those mentioned companies, and it will just work? If so, that is impressive and very useful. But I also have doubts that it is actually that transferable- surely there is some tweaking of options or env details needed? And if so, then I wouldn't apply the label "standard" to it.
A life lived in fear is a life half-lived
-
@bmann said in Standard package formats:
The website says that buildpacks has "been adopted by Cloud Foundry and other PaaS such as Google App Engine, Gitlab, Knative, Deis, Dokku, and Drie." Do I take this to mean that I can take any apps's buildpack, say from Heroku (or from any of those listed), and just run it in any of those mentioned companies, and it will just work? If so, that is impressive and very useful. But I also have doubts that it is actually that transferable- surely there is some tweaking of options or env details needed? And if so, then I wouldn't apply the label "standard" to it.
@scooke said in Standard package formats:
Do I take this to mean that I can take any apps's buildpack, say from Heroku (or from any of those listed), and just run it in any of those mentioned companies, and it will just work?
Yes. There is a growing list of platforms that support Buildpacks. There are some related efforts like nixpacks growing as well.
eg. here's Digital Ocean list of buildpacks they support https://docs.digitalocean.com/products/app-platform/reference/buildpacks/
-
@robi said in Standard package formats:
Perhaps you need to see the BayLISA talks about the origins and architecture of Cloudron.
@jdaviescoates @robi thanks! Here's the presentation https://assets.cloudron.io/presentations/baylisa-august-2019.pdf for others not clicking through / wanting a written version.
For context: I've been running and creating Heroku buildpacks since they launched 10+ years ago, precisely because buildpacks are simpler than Docker and make things easier for mortals to self host
Now, thinking about a broader "app store", and more hands maintaining common apps, I'm wondering about connecting with other communities to make lighter maintenance work.
Effectively: what is the difference between some-form-of-buildpacks and Cloudron's current packaging format?
-
@jdaviescoates @robi thanks! Here's the presentation https://assets.cloudron.io/presentations/baylisa-august-2019.pdf for others not clicking through / wanting a written version.
For context: I've been running and creating Heroku buildpacks since they launched 10+ years ago, precisely because buildpacks are simpler than Docker and make things easier for mortals to self host
Now, thinking about a broader "app store", and more hands maintaining common apps, I'm wondering about connecting with other communities to make lighter maintenance work.
Effectively: what is the difference between some-form-of-buildpacks and Cloudron's current packaging format?
@bmann said in Standard package formats:
Effectively: what is the difference between some-form-of-buildpacks and Cloudron's current packaging format?
Good question. You should find the information you need in https://docs.cloudron.io/packaging/manifest/
