ERPNext - cost-effective ERP solution

[MooCloud_Matt]

@nj said in ERPNext - cost-effective ERP solution:

Cloudron totally takes care of backup and restore and I have already tested it

Not really, cloudron takes a snapshot of /app/data, and your database I guess don't create a dump before that happened.
That's not really stable as a solution.

If you could like get a dump every x time, that could be a solution, even if not perfect

[nj]

@MooCloud_Matt you don’t need to take a database dump because the entire mariadb database lies inside the /app/data folder.

[MooCloud_Matt]

@nj
that is correct if you have ZFS or BTRFS, that can do a snapshot instantaneity.
But cloudron uses a simple compression or rsync, which means that from when it starts and when it stops it takes time and in that time, data could be changed and the relationship could come out corrupted.

postgress in their documentation, for example, suggests that if you want to use an fs snapshot you should stop the DB.

[LoudLemur]

@nj I do not know if it is permissable or even possible but how about trying to use the Cloudron Demo to setup uour ERPNext?
We could take a look at it there.

@girish ?

[nj]

@LoudLemur you are right in that case. I didn’t worry because my backup schedule is at 3:00AM when nobody really used the app. If you expect people to write to the database during backup that’s an issue for sure.

Fortunately, ErpNext has a solution for that. We can put the app in maintenance mode for a while, and as I have already setup this ErpNext package to allow database read operations during maintenance, only writes will fail, which means websites etc will still be working fine.

Unfortunately, Cloudron doesn’t have a scheduler or cron system that can trigger a script before starting to backup and another script after backup success / failure. If @girish added a cron format like @prebackup @postbackup and @onbackupfail or simply added those options to the scheduler manifest, it would be perfect.

Either we could put the app in maintenance mode right before backup and put the site back on afterwards . I could even run mariadb inside /run/mariadb instead of /app/data ; I would only create database backup at /app/data/mariadb-dump-datetime.sql right before backup and delete it when backup task completes.

Also I’d like to see/know how the database addon handles backups and restoration.

[robi]

@nj said in ERPNext - cost-effective ERP solution:

Unfortunately, Cloudron doesn’t have a scheduler or cron system that can trigger a script before starting to backup and another script after backup success / failure. If @girish added a cron format like @prebackup @postbackup and @onbackupfail or simply added those options to the scheduler manifest, it would be perfect.

File a feature request for this to get it in their queue.

[yusf]

@nj Thanks for packaging ERPNext. Its potential is vast.

Trying out different features of it I notice that there seem to be several modules missing when compared to the ERPNext docs.

For example Automation is missing. (Though I can reach and use event producers by searching for it, or reaching /app/event-producer directly)

Perhaps that's all in order if your app is packing the core app only?

[nj]

@yusf I have setup frappe to install ErpNext only. If Automation is an app, you can add any apps you like. Instructions on Github. I also installed other apps after installing this package on my cloudron. Or maybe Automation module is hidden by default and you can show it from Settings, I don’t know.

[nj]

I spent several days to make ErpNext work with Cloudron MySQL or Postgres. Unfortunately, postgres support is still a work in progress in ErpNext upstream and the project uses some features like CREATE SEQUENCE that are only available in MySQL, not in MariaDB. That's why the current version of this package is the most stable one.

My suggestion to @staff if you can, please add the MariaDB addon alongside the MySQL addon. It should be extremely easy to add because of the similarity with MySQL. There are so many open source software that use MariaDB, and will sooner or later be incompatible with MySQL.

[JLX89]

@staff anything further thoughts on this?

[girish]

@JLX89 doesn't seem like it's easy to host this on Cloudron yet. TBH, I don't think we will be able to support this sort of selfhosting complexity.

[LoudLemur]

@girish said in ERPNext - cost-effective ERP solution:

TBH, I don't think we will be able to support this sort of selfhosting complexity.

Cloudron does brilliantly at hosting Nextcloud, which I think is a somewhat similar, complex application. What is it about Nextcloud which makes it possible where ERPnext is too tricky?

[girish]

@LoudLemur you can see this post by @nj who already spent 100+ hours on this. The app also (when previously investigated) required database admin credentials and had restrictions on how username/password is created etc. All this makes it basically unviable for selfhosting imo, in general. I am sure it can be made to run with Cloudron with a lot of effort , but it's not worth it (for us).

[timconsidine]

Totally understand @girish
My 2p : "big" systems deserve their own dedicated deployment, e.g. own VPS

[JLX89]

@girish Thank you for following up! Yes, that makes total sense.

[nilesh]

@girish Were these issues ever reported to ERPNext? I couldn't find any mention of cloudron ever in their repository: https://github.com/frappe/erpnext/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+cloudron

[nilesh]

[zonzonzon]

Is the ERPNext package on Cloudron still operational at this point? It has been a long time since I’ve seen any updates on this topic @nj

[nj]

Yes, the package still works.

New Installation using my image

To directly install ERPNext if you haven't previously, use this command:
Remember to replace <yourdomain.com> with youre actual domain.

cloudron login my.<yourdomain.com>
cloudron install --image njsubedi/cloudron-erpnext -l erp.<yourdomain.com>

Open the file manager to look for the credentials.

If you need to login with LDAP, you can do that by using the terminal of this app, and run /app/pkg/setup-ldap.sh add

Otherwise, that's all you need to do.

Updating

If you previously used ths app and want to continue using version-14, you need to do is run gosu cloudron bench update --reset once in a while to keep things up to date.

Now, I have upgraded the code to use version-15 by default.

If you were previously running on version-14 and now need to update to version-15 that's pretty easy too.

Just run gosu cloudron bench switch-to-branch version-15 frappe erpnext --upgrade

Then run gosu cloudron bench migrate

[zonzonzon]

@nj Hello, what is the most optimal method for backing up data from Cloudron currently, especially for ERPNext on Cloudron? Thank you.