UNSOLVED How to configure LDAP in Discourse?
This was previously posted in the Discourse App wishlist topic.
I'm trying to add LDAP support myself. I've added the ldap addon to the package manifest, built and installed it. I've also installed the discourse-ldap-auth plugin. It sort of works!
Here are the settings I could figure out myself:
invite-onlyforums that only want LDAP, that setting has to be turned off. Otherwise LDAP users can't authenticate. The feature can still be achieved by
enable local logins
enable local logins via email
allow new registrations(Brings back the Sign up button, but luckily (!?) it leads to LDAP login too.
- Accounts aren't automatically created. (Not possible currently)
- I don't know what
en_US.login.ldap.nameis or how to map it/fix it.
- I don't know how to map the suggested username to the Cloudron username upon Discourse account creation. I would also want to lock it.
- I don't know any other LDAP settings, I just ripped them from the Wordpress LDAP integration settings
- LDAP sign-in UI looks off-brand and dodgy, possibly signalling phishing attempt for some users.
Any help appreciated!
This was the app that I had running via cloudron OAuth that got broken! I knew there was one...this has just become a bit of a problem for me too
If the LDAP add-on is enabled for the app at least, it should be able to bind and authenticate even if it means manually copying credentials. I may have to steal them from another app (bad!) in the mean time though since I'm getting complaints from users
It would also be pretty trivial for me to fork and update this plugin to work more automatically with limited configuration for cloudron specifically and cleaning up things like that
en_US.login.ldap.namewhich is an i18n key
yusf last edited by yusf
@yusf I'm not gonna say yes at this point since syncing requires some sort of cron-like setup and I'm just not sure how involved that would be - I mostly meant reading those settings in from the LDAP add-on without having to copy them into the admin UI from the app's console.
I wouldn't rule it out, but if we could get that to be the only outstanding "issue" it strikes me that would be substantial progress for a start
yusf last edited by yusf
I see. I don't know where the plugin data is stored but I suppose the official package can be modified to include the LDAP addon, the plugin and its settings.
My personal incentive however, is to improve the experience for users (wrt the bullets above). Package automation can come later.
Gets a little technical about ruby and how discourse manages the plugins, but that all sort of goes hand-in-hand. Depending how the next day or two go, I'll see about doing something that we can use in order to keep the conversation moving and have a base to tackle some of those features from. Appreciate the context of your goals; I'll bear that in mind when the code starts flying
@jimcavoli Did any code start flying?
@yusf Not as of yet...last few weeks have been very long hours for me on a litany of other things. I'll hopefully be getting some time back in a week or two
Were the issues related to account creation sorted out?
@yusf If I understand the current situation, if the LDAP plugin is enabled:
- User logs in.
- User sees a screen to 'create new account'. User has to just click through.
Is this the case? If so, that does not seem like a major issue.
@girish That's correct. There are more oddities around depending on what default use case you would go with for the package. (walled garden, open registration+ldap etc)
@yusf To keep you updated, I looked into this a bit further. The issue is that when we add ldap as addon, Cloudron UI selects this as the default. For an app like discourse, using LDAP is uncommon since it's mostly a publicly forum use case.
I think before we add LDAP support to nodebb/discourse etc, we need to fix Cloudron to support "dynamic addons". This way one can toggle LDAP support on/off whenever they want. That's the best way to fix this. Otherwise, I suspect, people will blindly install Discourse with LDAP, then disable LDAP inside Discourse and this will only lead to problems (since in Cloudron packages currently we assume that LDAP support is never removed like that inside an app).
@girish Seems like an apt solution to the problem. Thanks for looking into it.
For what it’s worth I’m often faced with the opposite use-case: some group need internal forum software, apart from other Cloudron services. So I’m interested in doing the same thing with NodeBB.
jdaviescoates last edited by
For an app like discourse, using LDAP is uncommon since it's mostly a publicly forum use case.
Even in those cases it'd still be nice to have LDAP, like we can in Rocket.Chat right now, i.e. Cloudron uses can use LDAP to login to Rocket.Chat using their Clourdon credentials, and non-Cloudron users can just register and login as normal too.
I'd like the same UX for Discourse too, best of both worlds!
@girish And meanwhile if I want to go venture off with a forked Discourse app with the only difference being that the LDAP addon is added, I should be able to stay compatible with the official one within foreseeable future, right?
@yusf Yes, it should remain compatible. I haven't gotten time to updating the Dockerfile to have the LDAP plugin pre-installed and pre-configured. If you have the code for that, I can look into merging it.
jdaviescoates last edited by jdaviescoates
@girish yet another reason for having the LDAP plugin for Discourse pre-installed and pre-configured on Cloudron would be so that we can start to try and reverse engineer the new Discourse Teams as much as possible (sadly it's not all open source, although as I understand it lots of the features are just using open source plugins)
More info about the difference between Discourse and Discourse Teams:
Edit: and following my prompts they've now added the list of open source plugins they use in Teams to that support link, i.e.
Ships with the following official plugins: akismet, assign, cakeday, calendar, chat-integration, checklist, code-review, docs, encrypt, footnote, github, graphviz, math, openid-connect, policy, rss-polling, solved, spoiler-alert
Sorry. Got to the party too late. Today I installed the LDAP plugin from here https://github.com/jonmbake/discourse-ldap-auth and took some ldap creds from my wekan app.
Short info: both user managements lives together in harmony
In my understanding the sign-up process goes to discourse user management. LDAP is only for the sign-in process (makes sense).
The only glitch at the moment:
Disabling LDAP in the Plugin settings doesn't change anything.
My 2 cents for the moment: please add the LDAP addon to this app, because of the plugin and some use cases, where LDAP makes sense.
@girish nope. same, same.