Docs - Alternative to Notion / Outline with OIDC, GDPR compliant, PDF Export (with template) etc...
-
v3.3 is out: https://github.com/suitenumerique/docs/releases/tag/v3.3.0
Also mentioned in the Self-Host github section:"In the works: Docker Compose, YunoHost"
Would be great to see Cloudron in there.
-
I agree with you, now if you compare the NextCloud compose setup https://github.com/nextcloud/docker?tab=readme-ov-file#running-this-image-with-docker-compose with the one for Docs : https://github.com/suitenumerique/docs/blob/main/docker-compose.yml you will notice that due to the plethora of services and setup required for Docs to work, this is not so-easy to port Docs on Cloudron. Not technically impossible
, but still there is lot of chirurgy required. I guess it could take days worth of work (testing and rework and hacks) just to make it work til it breaks on next major upgrade. I guess at this point it's likely best to run Docs on a dedicated VPS rather than risking having unstable Docs on Cloudron. -
I agree with you, now if you compare the NextCloud compose setup https://github.com/nextcloud/docker?tab=readme-ov-file#running-this-image-with-docker-compose with the one for Docs : https://github.com/suitenumerique/docs/blob/main/docker-compose.yml you will notice that due to the plethora of services and setup required for Docs to work, this is not so-easy to port Docs on Cloudron. Not technically impossible
, but still there is lot of chirurgy required. I guess it could take days worth of work (testing and rework and hacks) just to make it work til it breaks on next major upgrade. I guess at this point it's likely best to run Docs on a dedicated VPS rather than risking having unstable Docs on Cloudron.@SansGuidon - thanks for your reply.
Just to be clear: I am not in hiding and know/understand that in the current state, it would take an important amount of work to make this happen on Cloudron.I suppose I am coming from a slightly different angle: if they mentioned that Docker Compose and YunoHost are work in progress, then they might be open to also work on making it happen for Cloudron and thus make some accommodating changes from their end too -> "going at it from both side and we meet in the middle" kind of situation.
However, this would ask someone with Cloudron packaging / deployment to get in touch with them and discuss what is possible.
-
I think shipping for YunoHost and Docker compose almost is similar work for them, while shipping for Cloudron which is not packaging with Docker Compose at all, would take them too much work. A bit like shipping a video game for BSD or Linux for a couple users, while your main market is at ease using Windows. Not only the initial work would be plenty, but also the maintenance for them, without having lot of ROI, would be a decision factor. Thus if we want such app on Cloudron, which is less known, we will likely need to do the work ourselves, because the way Cloudron package apps is a specific format which is not compatible with Docker compose at all.
EDIT: Related = https://forum.cloudron.io/topic/11580/support-for-docker-compose/3
-
I am also following their matrix channel and the app seems to be still under heavy development. My idea was to package it once they remove the beta tag on their website, but maybe we can look into the packaging side already earlier.
-
I am also following their matrix channel and the app seems to be still under heavy development. My idea was to package it once they remove the beta tag on their website, but maybe we can look into the packaging side already earlier.
-
v3.4 is out and brings nested pages apparently: https://github.com/suitenumerique/docs/releases/tag/v3.4.0
-
I am also following their matrix channel and the app seems to be still under heavy development. My idea was to package it once they remove the beta tag on their website, but maybe we can look into the packaging side already earlier.
@nebulon said in Docs - Alternative to Notion / Outline with OIDC, GDPR compliant, PDF Export (with template) etc...:
My idea was to package it once they remove the beta tag on their website
I don't see any mention of beta on their website nor on their repository.
-
Indeed looks like they removed all the beta labels by now. Maybe I will get around looking at the package over the weekend.
@nebulon said in Docs - Alternative to Notion / Outline with OIDC, GDPR compliant, PDF Export (with template) etc...:
Indeed looks like they removed all the beta labels by now. Maybe I will get around looking at the package over the weekend.
This looks like a really great piece of software so that would be AMAZING!
-
Indeed looks like they removed all the beta labels by now. Maybe I will get around looking at the package over the weekend.
@nebulon said in Docs - Alternative to Notion / Outline with OIDC, GDPR compliant, PDF Export (with template) etc...:
Indeed looks like they removed all the beta labels by now. Maybe I will get around looking at the package over the weekend.
This would be fantastic and much appreciated.
-
Indeed looks like they removed all the beta labels by now. Maybe I will get around looking at the package over the weekend.
@nebulon said in Docs - Alternative to Notion / Outline with OIDC, GDPR compliant, PDF Export (with template) etc...:
Indeed looks like they removed all the beta labels by now. Maybe I will get around looking at the package over the weekend.
Just wondering... did you manage to have a look and make some progress?
