Agate+ (dual protocol server to serve gemini/http from one source)

[timconsidine]

@robi yep, I need to remind myself about it.
I have a vague distant feeling that it didn’t deal with the core issue that less techie users would still struggle with it. But hey, grey hair, don’t even recall my name some days, let me review it. Maybe the truth is I didn’t understand it at the time

[timconsidine]

@LoudLemur hey, did you see my post about CCAI ?
You can now use https://ccai.appx.uk to deploy custom apps to your own cloudron.
Anonymous - no login details saved.

Details : https://forum.cloudron.io/post/110907

[LoudLemur]

@timconsidine Hey, thanks! No, I missed that. I shall take a look.

WOW!

So all we need is to link a publicly accessible git and Docker image, and it does the magic for us?

Amazing! Surely, there must be more to it than that...?

[timconsidine]

@LoudLemur basically yes, simple as that, "magic" is behind the scenes

I'm cautious about the word "link", could be understood differently.

CCAI does this :

1. asks for :

• your cloudron domain e.g. my.cloudron-instance.tld (never stored)
• your user name (never stored)
• your password (never stored)
• your 2FA code (if you've enabled this, otherwise leave blank)
  If it logs in successfully,

2. asks for :

• git repo of the target custom app, e.g. https://git.cloudron.io/timconsidine/cloudron-agate-plus
• prebuilt docker image, e.g. tcmbp132021/cloudron-agate-plus:v6.36
• location where you want the custom app to deploy, e.g. your-gemini.your-domain.tld
• any port binding needed : optional in most cases, also optional for your first installation of Agate+, but subsequent instances need "GEMINI_PORT=1967" or higher number

So it's a bit more than just linking, but it's much easier than installing and using CLI, installing and using docker to build, installing and using a docker registry.

[timconsidine]

CCAI now has an "app picker" to populate necessary install data fields.

@LoudLemur Agate+ is one of the custom apps in the list

So is @DidierMalenfant Agate package, which is great for dedicated gemini site hosting.

[LoudLemur]

@timconsidine Exciting!
I like the idea of that App Picker!

I see it and tried, however it failed as another installation to the same cloudron was already in progress.

(I have been trying to package and deploy another custom application. I thought that process had ground to a halt, but the notification indicates that tcmbp thinks it is still trying...)

[timconsidine]

@LoudLemur errr
No idea, sorry
Have you tried doing one at a time ?

[robi]

@timconsidine I got the same message.

I tried to login, failed the first time, fixed typo from entered data, logged in.

Selected your agate+ package, then got the message it's already in progress.

Thoughts:
See if the error state is interfering between tries.
Make sure to clear it on every submission, not just starting over.
It's annoying that each field starts with capital letter on mobile.
Would help to have ports prefilled like in your app.

Update: tried again from scratch, no error modal, still got the failure.
Then switched to the other agate app and got this: Unsupported git hosting service.

Doesn't like self hosted domains other than github and cloudron. Lol

I'd upload a screenshot but can't seem to paste or upload from this mobile browser.

[robi]

Seems you have to start with the image first.

[timconsidine]

This post is deleted!

[timconsidine]

@robi thank you for the analysis

Yes, unsupported git hosting service is the critical error. I will remove the standard Agate package from the list until I can confirm Dider's git details.

@DidierMalenfant what is the git service behind "https://code.malenfant.net/didier/agate-app " ?
I can try to add support for it.
Also does it need port binding to be set ?

I will check my Agate+ settings again.

[LoudLemur]

Agate+ installed using https://ccai.appx.uk/ and the nice, new "Quick Setup" option.

• The port field 19XX was a bit confusing. If you leave it like that, the installation doesn't work. For the quick setup, how about suggesting 1965 and a note/tool-tip for changing this if needed

• I don't think that ccai checks to see if another installation is happening at the same time before attempting to start. In something like a college setting, lots of people might be trying to use the same service at the same time in a class.

• The reverse proxy for additional servers is a nice tool. I tried using the terminal as suggested to setup an additional server using the initial one as a reverse proxy, but it failed.

/app/code# register-new-instance.sh
bash: register-new-instance.sh: command not found

[timconsidine]

I could not replicate the errors.
So I tweaked the CCAI installer to be more aggressive on clearing past installation attempts, as robi and loudlemur mentioned multiple attempts.

NB : if you're doing repeat installs, it's definitely worth using the [Start Over] but maybe you did.

NB : when installing to a subdomain not used before, Cloudron's reverse proxy registration can be variable (fast to slow). Patience required

I also cleared Didier's package details until they can be verified.

I used CCAI to install a new instance of Agate+ and made a video.

Note : for the first installation of Agate+, the port binding needs to be clear or set to GEMINI_PPORT=1965.
For additional installations, port binding needs to be GEMIN_PORT=1967 or higher if you have other installations. And in your first installation of Agate+, register your 2nd etc instance. See POSTINSTALL.md in the 1st instance, which is shown on the app settings dashboard.

No privilege to post the install demo here, so it's over here : https://ccai-demo.appx.uk/
This might flush out any difference in the way I am doing it.

Other thoughts :

• use [Start Over] between install attempts
• reload or force reload the browser page between install attempts
• check in your Cloudron whether an app was created despite failed install, and manually uninstall it through the Cloudron app dashboard before trying again

[timconsidine]

Pushed small tweak to cloudron git and to hosted docker image (v 6.3.7)

[robi]

@timconsidine said in Agate+ (dual protocol server to serve gemini/http from one source):

@DidierMalenfant what is the git service behind "https://code.malenfant.net/didier/agate-app " ?
I can try to add support for it.

His is just a Gitea instance, so should be fine. It should fail on the git command attempt, not the URL check.

I'd also like to keep my cloudron info while installing other apps, until the browser window is closed.
Why log in every time?

Same for subdomain and port settings, keep the TLD and have a default port for first installs, we know to increment on additional installs.

[robi]

@LoudLemur said in Agate+ (dual protocol server to serve gemini/http from one source):

/app/code# register-new-instance.sh
bash: register-new-instance.sh : command not found

That's because it's in /app/data

Take a look in the App Terminal or File Manager

[robi]

@timconsidine Can you add a checkbox to an app anyone installs to submit it to your list of available packages once a successful install has taken place?

Private apps remain private if left unchecked.

[robi]

Btw, your Agate+ app doesn't seem to complete health check, hence remains Starting... & unclickable from UI.

[timconsidine]

@robi really ?! Not good, sorry.
Works for me though !
Let me investigate further.

Are you installing manually or through ccai.appx.uk ?
Is this with v6.37 (latest - uploaded to cloudron git this evening) ?

Just so I know what to investigate

[robi]

@timconsidine said in Agate+ (dual protocol server to serve gemini/http from one source):

Are you installing manually or through ccai.appx.uk ?
Using your ccai

Is this with v6.37 (latest - uploaded to cloudron git this evening) ?

v6.37, pkg v 3.3.17

I installed it twice, once with the port set to 1968, then uninstalled, and installed again with your new instructions to delete the port field, same result.

App works, but Cloudron doesn't know.