ERPNext - cost-effective ERP solution
-
@nj said in ERPNext - cost-effective ERP solution:
frappe framework requires the database name and database username to be the same (its hardcoded and all over the place). When testing locally it worked but in cloudron, db name is appended with “db” and username with “user”
That's a pretty rough requirement
but we can fix the platform code I guess to have an option to generate such names.frappe framework needs root access to the database, eg. password of the user named “postgres” (its hardcoded, even if —dbroot-username exists, it’s for mariadb only)
Keeps getting rougher
There's no chance we will allow an app to have root db access.Is the situation any better with mariadb instead of postgresql?
@girish for the initial release, I've given up on the idea of using Cloudron addons for now. Postgres is also getting over-complicated so I think I'd stick with MariaDB. Let's see how it goes. The build-run-test cycle is quite tedious when there are all kinds of new errors to resolve. ErpNext turned out to be a lot harder than I expected.
Current status: frappe installed, up and running. ErpNext won't install, and require all its dependencies (apps) to be installed. My target is to publish it by this week.
-
frappe framework needs root access to the database
Surely this is not actually necessary to run the app, but is just part of their custom dynamic deployment system (ick). I hope it's possible to extricate the actual app from the framework...
@infogulch said in ERPNext - cost-effective ERP solution:
frappe framework needs root access to the database
Surely this is not actually necessary to run the app, but is just part of their custom dynamic deployment system (ick). I hope it's possible to extricate the actual app from the framework...
I thought so too. Unfortunately, it keeps asking for "postgres super user password".
-
@girish for the initial release, I've given up on the idea of using Cloudron addons for now. Postgres is also getting over-complicated so I think I'd stick with MariaDB. Let's see how it goes. The build-run-test cycle is quite tedious when there are all kinds of new errors to resolve. ErpNext turned out to be a lot harder than I expected.
Current status: frappe installed, up and running. ErpNext won't install, and require all its dependencies (apps) to be installed. My target is to publish it by this week.
-
Help Needed. Please check issue on github.
I'm inches away from either successfully running ErpNext or quitting the idea of packaging it. Never had I ever stuck with this kind of stupid errors.
When everything goes smooth, one of the modules (Payment Module in particular) make the entire table crash in the middle of loading the modules. Fix one error, then another pops up, then another.
I no longer have time nor patience to package this after this week. Here's the progress.. github.com/njsubedi/cloudron-erpnext if anyone has time, skill and patience, please go ahead and continue packaging this piece of sofware.
If anyone knows people from Frappe, please tell them to stop putting spaces and uppercase letters in table names, and at least retry any database operation instead of leaving the entire database in broken state when something fails, then have the user restart the minutes long process from the beginning.
Hours spent: 100+
Please check the issue on Github
-
Help Needed. Please check issue on github.
I'm inches away from either successfully running ErpNext or quitting the idea of packaging it. Never had I ever stuck with this kind of stupid errors.
When everything goes smooth, one of the modules (Payment Module in particular) make the entire table crash in the middle of loading the modules. Fix one error, then another pops up, then another.
I no longer have time nor patience to package this after this week. Here's the progress.. github.com/njsubedi/cloudron-erpnext if anyone has time, skill and patience, please go ahead and continue packaging this piece of sofware.
If anyone knows people from Frappe, please tell them to stop putting spaces and uppercase letters in table names, and at least retry any database operation instead of leaving the entire database in broken state when something fails, then have the user restart the minutes long process from the beginning.
Hours spent: 100+
Please check the issue on Github
@nj You might not want to hear this, but in 100 hours, you could probably reproduce anything you need from ERPNext in EspoCRM using the Entity Manager to build copies of any specific data structures and Reports for anything specific there.
That's basically a lot of what I've been doing lately, taking Espo from being a CRM to an ERP system.
Web Design https://www.evergreen.je
Development https://brandlight.org
Life https://marcusquinn.com -
@nj You might not want to hear this, but in 100 hours, you could probably reproduce anything you need from ERPNext in EspoCRM using the Entity Manager to build copies of any specific data structures and Reports for anything specific there.
That's basically a lot of what I've been doing lately, taking Espo from being a CRM to an ERP system.
-
@marcusquinn I could do the entire EspoCRM in Directus if I had to.
I wanted to package it because it's one of the most wanted apps, but I think it takes someone else who knows python and databases more than me.
@nj After 18 months working with Espo, I doubt it, and I'm a fan of Directus too.
I see value in having ERPNext, and Odoo, packaged and available too. Even if only so that people can compare all of these similar apps, and take inspiration from all of them to make the best solution with the one they choose to develop among them.
I think you're right though, this one needs cooperation from the original author if it's not versatile enough to handle errors in building in Cloudron's tighter security Docker environment.
-
Trailer
You know what's disappointing? I started packaging ERPNext for the HR module. Unfortunately, the HR Module is not available after installation. Now I'm here thinking where the hell it go, and why I spent weeks packaging something that doesn't have the particular module I was looking for.Update: Looks like
version-14of ERPNext does not have HR module. Onlyversion-13has it. Now packaging version 13.
Founder / Coder • My Apps
-
Trailer
You know what's disappointing? I started packaging ERPNext for the HR module. Unfortunately, the HR Module is not available after installation. Now I'm here thinking where the hell it go, and why I spent weeks packaging something that doesn't have the particular module I was looking for.Update: Looks like
version-14of ERPNext does not have HR module. Onlyversion-13has it. Now packaging version 13.@nj said in ERPNext - cost-effective ERP solution:
Looks like version-14 of ERPNext does not have HR module.
They refactored the HR and Payroll module into a "new" app --> #31467. Maybe this could still be installed within the current V14 docker app --> ERPNext HRMS installation.
PS: Thank you for your hard work
-
@nj said in ERPNext - cost-effective ERP solution:
Looks like version-14 of ERPNext does not have HR module.
They refactored the HR and Payroll module into a "new" app --> #31467. Maybe this could still be installed within the current V14 docker app --> ERPNext HRMS installation.
PS: Thank you for your hard work
-
@nj Not sure if this is what you are looking for, but if you wish to put on a donation pot, I would be happy to contribute where I can, as a token of thanks for your hard work and time!
Thank you again for all the hard work.@Aizat I'm looking for someone who know MariaDB and Python3 for the project. I've successfully packaged ErpNext, but I had to patch the source code of "Payments" and "HRMS" modules that crash the database tables during installation. Instead of cash, I'm looking for few other people who would pull the repo, and see if they see the same kind of crashes.
-
@nj I tried installing it to my cloudron and it built successfully, but I ran into an issue with the cloudron cli during installation saying that I need to specify a subdomain (when I clearly did specify a subdomain), then I ran out of time to mess with it until later this week.
-
Okay, here is the good news. Please try it out and let me know if it works.
If you're not ready to build the image yourself, you can simply install the image that I created.
cloudron install --image njsubedi/cloudron-erpnext -l erp.<yourdomain.tld>.ErpNext v14 is now available on Cloudron. See the README file for usage instructions.
Features
- ErpNext v14 - running on Frappe Framework v14
- HRMS Module - Includes HR and Payroll modules
- Plug n Play - Automatically configured to use the subdomain you install it on, no setup needed
- Independent - Does not depend on Cloudron Addons for redis, mysql or such
Gotchas
- Installs its own database servers, but data resides inside /app/data, so it gets backed-up, no not a big issue
- Hasn't been tested a lot, but it's working pretty fine
- Multi-tenancy isn't set up, even though that's pretty trivial to do
Good to know
- After installation, look into
/app/datafolder using cloudron's file manager for a file that ends with-credential.txt. - Raise issues on Github if you run into problems, not here.
Founder / Coder • My Apps
-
Okay, here is the good news. Please try it out and let me know if it works.
If you're not ready to build the image yourself, you can simply install the image that I created.
cloudron install --image njsubedi/cloudron-erpnext -l erp.<yourdomain.tld>.ErpNext v14 is now available on Cloudron. See the README file for usage instructions.
Features
- ErpNext v14 - running on Frappe Framework v14
- HRMS Module - Includes HR and Payroll modules
- Plug n Play - Automatically configured to use the subdomain you install it on, no setup needed
- Independent - Does not depend on Cloudron Addons for redis, mysql or such
Gotchas
- Installs its own database servers, but data resides inside /app/data, so it gets backed-up, no not a big issue
- Hasn't been tested a lot, but it's working pretty fine
- Multi-tenancy isn't set up, even though that's pretty trivial to do
Good to know
- After installation, look into
/app/datafolder using cloudron's file manager for a file that ends with-credential.txt. - Raise issues on Github if you run into problems, not here.
@nj said in ERPNext - cost-effective ERP solution:
Okay, here is the good news. Please try it out and let me know if it works.
If you're not ready to build the image yourself, you can simply install the image that I created.
cloudron install --image njsubedi/cloudron-erpnext -l erp.<yourdomain.tld>.ErpNext v14 is now available on Cloudron. See the README file for usage instructions.
Features
- ErpNext v14 - running on Frappe Framework v14
- HRMS Module - Includes HR and Payroll modules
- Plug n Play - Automatically configured to use the subdomain you install it on, no setup needed
- Independent - Does not depend on Cloudron Addons for redis, mysql or such
Gotchas
- Installs its own database servers, but data resides inside /app/data, so it gets backed-up, no not a big issue
- Hasn't been tested a lot, but it's working pretty fine
- Multi-tenancy isn't set up, even though that's pretty trivial to do
Good to know
- After installation, look into
/app/datafolder using cloudron's file manager for a file that ends with-credential.txt. - Raise issues on Github if you run into problems, not here.
You are a Free Software hero right there, @nj !
-
Okay, here is the good news. Please try it out and let me know if it works.
If you're not ready to build the image yourself, you can simply install the image that I created.
cloudron install --image njsubedi/cloudron-erpnext -l erp.<yourdomain.tld>.ErpNext v14 is now available on Cloudron. See the README file for usage instructions.
Features
- ErpNext v14 - running on Frappe Framework v14
- HRMS Module - Includes HR and Payroll modules
- Plug n Play - Automatically configured to use the subdomain you install it on, no setup needed
- Independent - Does not depend on Cloudron Addons for redis, mysql or such
Gotchas
- Installs its own database servers, but data resides inside /app/data, so it gets backed-up, no not a big issue
- Hasn't been tested a lot, but it's working pretty fine
- Multi-tenancy isn't set up, even though that's pretty trivial to do
Good to know
- After installation, look into
/app/datafolder using cloudron's file manager for a file that ends with-credential.txt. - Raise issues on Github if you run into problems, not here.
@nj
bonus points to you sir! 
-
I infogulch referenced this topic on
-
Can somebody review the code?
@girish what else needs to be done so that it can be released as an unstable app in the store?
Some concerns:
- only dev branch for hrms and payment module and no release (yes I'm aware that only the dev branch exists - this has to be adressed in the future)
- does not use Cloudrons Redis
- Will some of the database mitigations break the insallation in the future?
I will wait until the unstable release at the Cloudron App Store and start testing then
-
I’ve added Cloudron LDAP support. I’ll push the changes this evening.
I think I can do Cloudron redis too. Looks doable.
I think after the default site is created, I can dump the db and import that to cloudron MySQL, but still ErpNext devs recommend Mariadb support only, and it needs the database name to be the same as the db user name. Unless there’s support from Cloudron devs, it’s a blocker. But I have set db path to be inside /app/data, so backup is not an issue. Also tried migration and backup-restore, which worked fine.
Since I’m actively using it at my company I’ll keep supporting this app. Also Keycloak, Outline and Odoo.
