Unsolved Gitlab how to run container registry

[parhelium]

Hi,

I would like to build and store docker images using Gitlab for deploying my projects to gitlab instance managed by cloudron.

Gitlab Container Registry must be installed and turn on.

Have anybody did that ?
https://docs.gitlab.com/ee/administration/container_registry.html

Thanks in advance

[pedrofernandez]

@parhelium nope but im interested too, hope someone can help asap! thanks

[girish]

Sorry for the delay, but we are looking into this.

[atzen]

I'm looking forward to it. This would help me a lot

[eyecreate]

Now with Docker this year mentioning no long term storage of docker images for free accounts, this will be even more valuable to have in gitlab.

[robi]

Installation

There is no “installation” to speak of, as it’s integrated into GitLab itself. You rather need to activate it, and it’s easy.

If you have a GitLab omnibus there is only one line to edit in your gitlab.rb:

registry_external_url 'https://gitlab.example.com:4443'

[subven]

Pushing this because I want to use the registry feature and it shouldn't be that hard to implement it. Has nobody solved this so far?

@robi can you further explain how this could be done in the current cloudron gitlab app? AFAIK gitlab.yml is read only and I don't think it's usefull to mess around with the templates.

Official documentation: https://docs.gitlab.com/omnibus/settings/configuration.html
Registry config at Cloudron template: https://git.cloudron.io/cloudron/gitlab-app/-/blob/master/config_templates/gitlab.yml#L427

[robi]

@subven It looks like it's already enabled as a feature, but not configured in the ~/gitlab/config/gitlab.yml

You can uncomment the relevant lines and try it.
Remember to keep it bound to the container & domain.

I'll let @girish chime in if it's been tested.

[mehdi]

It will not work. The gitlab container registry needs another domain (or another port).

[robi]

@mehdi so it might work as a sub.subdomain in a wildcard DNS config.

As for the port, that would be a manual adjustment of nginx and simpler.

[subven]

Although using a own subdomain for the registry would be a better approach, it is sufficient to use another port as described here.

Guide what has to be edited can be found --> https://dev.to/zaptic/how-to-gitlab-and-docker-registry-2moh

Edit: Full package documentation --> https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab/-/blob/master/doc/administration/packages/container_registry.md

[girish]

Trying to understand what kind of deployment people are interested in:

• Registry stores the images locally on the server itself. If so, we have to figure out how this will get backed up. Is there an interest in backing these things up or are people OK if these container images are "lost" (maybe since it's only used for building things in CI/CD).

• Registry is in another non-cloudron server. My understanding is this deployment is already possible but I have to try.

• Some external service is used as registry (for example, DO recently announced it's managed docker registry). Not sure if GitLab supports this.

[msbt]

The reason for my private docker registry: I want to keep my things on my own infrastructure and not somewhere public on docker hub. That's why I'm currently running my own docker registry from where I push the images to my cloudrons.

I migrated most of my custom apps to official cloudron apps (used to do custom WordPress and LAMPs for various reasons and some apps made it to the store), so only a few that aren't released yet (and some probably never will) are left, but those need to be available at all times - did a cloudron version update the other day and realized that the ssl cert of the registry needed a refresh, else the apps couldn't get reconfigured and would be in an erronous state. Would be nice to have a solution on some dev cloudron which handles those images so I don't have to run that single vm with the docker registry.

[girish]

@msbt how do you handle backups for the registry right now?

[msbt]

I don't, since those images can easily be rebuilt. It's a proxmox host and I've backed up the vm itself, it the server dies at some point, I'll just migrate to a different one.

[mehdi]

@girish The registry container just stores the images on its filesystem, doesn't it?

[girish]

@mehdi yes, but it seems one can also configure them to use S3 and the likes. I was just wondering what people usually do.

[subven]

@girish mainly I just want an all-in-one solution that works out of the box. Since registry comes (in most cases) bundled with Gitlab itself, this should be no problem. A crucial thing to look into would be container registry garbage collection since registry data can pile up easily. Basically it would be totally okay if the registry data were saved and backed up on the server itself. For small environments this would be fine and If you run a larger Gitlab instance you should be prepared anyways.

If Gitlab Registry is a seperate service, you could already use Cloudrons ability to configure backup bevavior and storage location. This would be nice for some use cases but not a basic requirement.

PS: For external/cloud storage you could already use MinIO which is available on Cloudron ^^

[mario]

@subven GitLab registry is basically "just" a configuration to use the registry api through GitLab. It's a regular Docker product - https://docs.docker.com/registry/

[girish]

I went down the container registry rabbit hole. In the end, it seems that it provides gitlab's authentication layer for the docker registry i.e users/groups/projects have same permissions in the registry as of gitlab. It has a limitation that the registry and the gitlab have to be on the same server. There is some strange path sharing requirement that I don't completely understand - https://docs.gitlab.com/ce/administration/packages/container_registry.html#use-file-system

I think an alternate approach is get Harbor working. It looks simple enough to deploy since it's a Go app and also has LDAP. This will then work with GitLab CI/CD (nice article). This won't bring in gitlab's auth into the registry though. Are people looking for something like that? (it seems something for big enterprises).

[robi]

@girish I just really need a private registry within cloudron.

Have private code waiting to become a private app and this is a show stopper road block.

[mario]

@girish I definitely have a use case for this despite not being a super-huge enterprise, which is why I'm trying to get it done. And I will - it's just a matter of time

I'm not against Harbor, etc. but I do need this to work which is why I'm on it

[girish]

@mario You left me a note somewhere on how to use the docker registry app with GitLab but I cannot find it anymore. Where did you put it?

[mario]

@girish README inside the repo: https://git.cloudron.io/cloudron/docker-registry-app

[girish]

@mario Sorry I missed the most obvious place, I was looking all over.