Jitsi
-
P plusone-nick referenced this topic on
-
Just in case - it seems like there is still an issue on having Jitsi working in NAT-ed environments (https://forum.cloudron.io/topic/7473/no-sound-in-jitsi/42)
-
A little bit off-topic: Mailbox.org is switching away from Jitsi according to their recent newsletter:
We would like to inform you about an important change to our
video conferencing services. [...] From March 1, 2024, we will only offer OpenTalk and discontinue Jitsi.Jitsi was once introduced as a temporary solution during the pandemic, but in our opinion is no longer fit for the future in terms of user-friendliness, security security and performance.
[...]
Your advantages with OpenTalk
Compared to Jitsi, OpenTalk offers an intuitive, friendly interface and improved voice and image quality. It can be used directly in the browser as usual. (And what will please technicians: It has a modern software architecture and is written in Rust, a programming language
programming language Rust). -
A little bit off-topic: Mailbox.org is switching away from Jitsi according to their recent newsletter:
We would like to inform you about an important change to our
video conferencing services. [...] From March 1, 2024, we will only offer OpenTalk and discontinue Jitsi.Jitsi was once introduced as a temporary solution during the pandemic, but in our opinion is no longer fit for the future in terms of user-friendliness, security security and performance.
[...]
Your advantages with OpenTalk
Compared to Jitsi, OpenTalk offers an intuitive, friendly interface and improved voice and image quality. It can be used directly in the browser as usual. (And what will please technicians: It has a modern software architecture and is written in Rust, a programming language
programming language Rust). -
A little bit off-topic: Mailbox.org is switching away from Jitsi according to their recent newsletter:
We would like to inform you about an important change to our
video conferencing services. [...] From March 1, 2024, we will only offer OpenTalk and discontinue Jitsi.Jitsi was once introduced as a temporary solution during the pandemic, but in our opinion is no longer fit for the future in terms of user-friendliness, security security and performance.
[...]
Your advantages with OpenTalk
Compared to Jitsi, OpenTalk offers an intuitive, friendly interface and improved voice and image quality. It can be used directly in the browser as usual. (And what will please technicians: It has a modern software architecture and is written in Rust, a programming language
programming language Rust).@necrevistonnezr said in Jitsi:
Mailbox.org is switching away
One bit of context that is not in the post is that OpenTalk is developed by the same people/company that are operating mailbox.org
-
@necrevistonnezr said in Jitsi:
Mailbox.org is switching away
One bit of context that is not in the post is that OpenTalk is developed by the same people/company that are operating mailbox.org
-
What about https://github.com/element-hq/element-call instead?
-
What about https://github.com/element-hq/element-call instead?
@potemkin_ai Doesn't seem like it's ready standalone: https://github.com/element-hq/element-call#host-it-yourself
-
@potemkin_ai Doesn't seem like it's ready standalone: https://github.com/element-hq/element-call#host-it-yourself
-
@robi you got to build it first, yep; going to follow that direction soon
@potemkin_ai cool, hopefully you can build it without the homeserver caveats.
-
@potemkin_ai cool, hopefully you can build it without the homeserver caveats.
@robi hope so; and what are the 'homeserver caveats' you mean?
-
@robi hope so; and what are the 'homeserver caveats' you mean?
@potemkin_ai they're detailed at the link above
-
@robi hope so; and what are the 'homeserver caveats' you mean?
@potemkin_ai in case you didn’t get a chance to find it (regarding the homeserver caveats):
By default, the app expects you to have a Matrix homeserver (such as Synapse) installed locally and running on port 8008…
Element Call requires a homeserver with registration enabled without any 3pid or token requirements, if you want it to be used by unregistered users…
Therefore, to use a self-hosted homeserver, this is recommended to be a new server where any user account created has not joined any normal rooms anywhere in the Matrix federated network.
It is for this reason that Element Call, while a robust and impressive solution the Matrix ecosystem, isn’t really a replacement (yet) for similar services. That being said, when deployed as part of an integrated Element Matrix solution such as Element Server Suite alongside Element X, it is incredible.
Jitsi Meet VideoBridge is crashing anytime more than two people join on any service that used it. It’s good that Element was working on Element Call before that. @girish and @nebulon, how was Cloudron able to run Jitsi so smoothly before when no other service could? Is that why the Cloudron version remained an older version?
-
Thanks, @aessen. I've been distracted, but now get back on that and have this up and running on a dedicated server - will see how it goes.
Jitsi is a working horse, can't say there are any troubles. Not running it inside Docker - got it running on a dedicated VM without problems; guess I'm now in a position to make it work well from inside the Docker, but can't find any motivation to do so.
My key insides from my short experience with Element Call:
- it's definitely not production ready - integration features wise, first of all
- guys basically probably took a look at Jitsi, which is an enhanced version of COTURN to mix things + XMPP server - for auth and signalling; then they probably looked at livekit and Synapse, scratched her heads and asked themselves: why bother with an external behemoth, when our product is a competitor with XMPP (given OMEMO could work as smoothly...)
- indeed existing Synapse server is a no go, unless you are ready for a mess
But the key problem turned out to be in other place: you can't just add element call URL to a well-known location / DNS and expect it to be catched by Element - it just won't.
Considering recent Element / Matrix reorganization and that the release cycle for Call is on a slow side and the tickets I've raised didn't get much attention, I wouldn't expect Element Call to be a production replacement soon.
-
Thanks, @aessen. I've been distracted, but now get back on that and have this up and running on a dedicated server - will see how it goes.
Jitsi is a working horse, can't say there are any troubles. Not running it inside Docker - got it running on a dedicated VM without problems; guess I'm now in a position to make it work well from inside the Docker, but can't find any motivation to do so.
My key insides from my short experience with Element Call:
- it's definitely not production ready - integration features wise, first of all
- guys basically probably took a look at Jitsi, which is an enhanced version of COTURN to mix things + XMPP server - for auth and signalling; then they probably looked at livekit and Synapse, scratched her heads and asked themselves: why bother with an external behemoth, when our product is a competitor with XMPP (given OMEMO could work as smoothly...)
- indeed existing Synapse server is a no go, unless you are ready for a mess
But the key problem turned out to be in other place: you can't just add element call URL to a well-known location / DNS and expect it to be catched by Element - it just won't.
Considering recent Element / Matrix reorganization and that the release cycle for Call is on a slow side and the tickets I've raised didn't get much attention, I wouldn't expect Element Call to be a production replacement soon.
@potemkin_ai Indeed, Jitsi itself, running alone, in its own comfy space, installed per the Jitsi guide does run smooth as silk (albeit with some occasional drops). It is when you get into other implementations that are not Debian/Ubuntu that it seems to have issues. I've tried the OpenSUSE and Docker deployments and eventually always encounter an issue with colibri/websockets.
As for Element Call, they seem really focused on their new Element Starter Suite and Element Server Suite which is a lot like Element Matrix Services (EMS) but self hosted. Element Call is part of some deployments and really sparkles there. What is really exciting is that the Integrations options have really revved up.
I am testing both suites now and can say this is the most complete Element has felt when self hosting and I am not just saying that because you can default your deployment to use Hydrogen instead if you want to cut some bloat. Ha-ha!
Element Server Suite can integrate with everything and the kitchen sink and is apparently the only one who Element Call wants to be friends with.
