SOLVED n8n.io - Zappier, IFTTT, Integromat alternative
-
n8n.io is a zappier, IFTT, opensource alternative.
-
I could get behind this. Looks very useful!
-
There seems to be lots of questions around licensing in the HN thread - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21191676
I am not even sure if we are 'allowed' to package it for Cloudron
-
Though not made with exactly the same approach there's a popular request for Huginn as well.
-
@girish said in n8n.io - Zappier, IFTTT, Integromat alternative:
I am not even sure if we are 'allowed' to package it for Cloudron
It sounds to me like you probably are allowed to do so:
May I create, distribute, offer as SaaS, and/or “sell” my products using Commons Clause licensed components?
Yes!
Commons Clause only forbids you from “selling” the Commons Clause software itself. You may develop on top of Commons Clause licensed software (adding applications, tools, utilities or plug-ins) and you may embed and redistribute Commons Clause software in a larger product, and you may distribute and even “sell” (which includes offering as a commercial SaaS service) your product. -
@jdaviescoates When this came out, the license was not Common Clause.
But now that we know the license and indeed Cloudron can redistribute it, I'm all for this to be ported here.
-
+1!
I'm looking forward to see this app as cloudron app! -
This is something! +1 from me
-
@hiyukoim said in n8n.io - Zappier, IFTTT, Integromat alternative:
+1!
I'm looking forward to see this app as cloudron app!@imc67 said in n8n.io - Zappier, IFTTT, Integromat alternative:
This is something! +1 from me
Just to be sure, have you both clicked on the little up ^ arrow on the post at the top of this thread?
Because that's how to +1 in a way that counts
-
Just to be sure, have you both clicked on the little up ^ arrow on the post at the top of this thread?
Because that's how to +1 in a way that counts
haha, ofcourse
-
Any signs of LDAP?
-
I would love to see this too
-
So I have an initial packaging for this done at https://git.cloudron.io/jimcavoli/n8n-app
HOWEVER, I'm honestly not sure I'd be comfortable putting this software into production as-is. It's pretty weak on some security features, but maybe its not the end of the world for people and I'm just super paranoid. There seems to be an undocumented way to do JWT auth, which I'm not going to even try to get into that, since I'm only aware of it from looking at the config file handling typescript code. The only supported authentication right now is basic auth as documented - with a single username/password set by ENV or config file (I went with the latter since it's easier for end-users to edit in
/app/data/.n8n/configby terminal).Either way, everything basically works, and by launching via supervisord with the working directory set to
/app/data/outputwe're able to contain its binary file writing to system (probably a bad thing to do in prod as well, but it works).Custom nodes can be added to
/app/data/custom, the config file is JSON at/app/data/.n8n/config, and the package writes cloudron-provided postgresql configuration to that file at launch.Some stuff only works in Chrome. That's just an issue with the app. Something about they way they're handling web sockets means other browsers see "Connection lost" in the top right, which is where the Activation toggle should be. Most other things actually work fine, but that's necessary for executing workflows in-browser manually and activating them.
I packaged this one because it seems to have some popularity in asks, but it definitely deserves some due diligence before heading to production for anyone or the app store. It's also pre-1.0 so not sure how much is changing how fast, and the setup as is was a pretty delicate thing to get done. Maybe my concerns are overplayed, maybe not, but either way, there's something we can start to kick the tires on for this app now.
-
@jimcavoli thanks for looking into this! The upstream projects seems to be quite active, so that is a good sign and probably things will improve then.
I've put it on my task list to take a look and then possiblly port it to the new base image and add some tests.
-
@jdaviescoates
haha,sure, of course I did
-
Hey @jimcavoli, good job with n8n, I've cloned your repo and played around a little. For whatever reason the basic auth wasn't working out of the box, so I added
ENV N8N_CONFIG_FILES="/app/data/.n8n/config"to the Dockerfile. Now auth works, but as soon as you restart the app for the first time, it won't come up anymore with that errormessage:Error: configuration param 'encryptionKey' not declared in the schema. It only gets back online after removing the encryptionKey entry in/app/data/.n8n/configand triggering another restart (which then again sets a new/different encryptionKey ).Any idea what's that about, or how did you get auth to work? It just ignores my settings without that env variable. If it's not set, restarts work, but auth does not.
A quick fix was to add another env var
ENV N8N_ENCRYPTION_KEY="123"to make the encryption key static (still had to delete it before restarting, but it sets the static one afterwards), else all saved credentials were unusable after restart and changed encryptionKey. Oviously that's not a solution, but at least I could test a little.Other than that (and updating to the latest version, base image and some minor tweaks) it seems to be working fine!
edit: not able to get webhooks to work, not sure if it's me or n8n
-
Today IFTTT announced that they will charge you $10 a month (!!!!) for their service. Maybe now it’s really time to put Cloudron in a unique position with this app?!
-
@imc67 Interesting. So existing free users have to pay or are they grand fathered?
-
@girish https://ifttt.com/plans
Create 3 Applets of your own
Turn on unlimited Applets -
@imc67 looks like perhaps there was a backlash, can now "set your price" starting at $1.99/mo
-
Got an email a few minutes ago from IFTTT;
Note: the free-forever IFTTT Standard plan no longer supports creating unlimited Applets from scratch.
To date, you’ve created more than 3 Applets. If you do not upgrade to Pro, all but 3 of your created Applets will be archived.
-
@imc67 yeah, I've got the same thing.
Most significantly, I think, is the last sentence:
Your current plan, the free-forever IFTTT Standard plan, no longer supports creating unlimited Applets from scratch.
To date, you’ve created more than 3 Applets. If you do not upgrade to Pro before October 7th, all but 3 of your custom Applets will be automatically archived.
For more information about archived Applets, see What happens if I do not upgrade to IFTTT Pro?
Through October 7th, you may set the monthly price you want to pay to upgrade to Pro and we’ll honor it forever.
Seems the Set your price options I mentioned above will likely disappear on October 7th... So I guess if you use IFTTT a lot it might be a good idea to pay $1.99/mo now (I actually hardly ever use it these days so think I'll just use self-hosted alternatives once they've been packaged for Cloudron).
-
Would definitely be interested in this. Specifically, my use-case is building my own smart light switches. Id have the buttons hooked up to microcontrollers that send requests to something like IFTTT or n8n off of a webhook trigger to turn lights on/off.
He/him | 🏳️🌈 | 🇨🇦 | 🇮🇷 | Lover of all things tech | “Full Stack” Dev @AMA
Site: atridad.dev -
@atrilahiji For this I suggest installing home-assistant locally on something like a raspberry pi, locally. I actually just installed such a system at my place
-
I looked into this a bit. Did I get it right that this app only supports basic auth? That's kinda worrying. I am surprised though given that it seems to have a lot of github stars atleast.
-
Thats what im seeing. Being able to use LDAP for this would be a godsend but I didnt find info on using LDAP with it. RIP the IFTTT alternative dream?
-
Just chatting with @murgero to look at this. Please pledge some sponsorship if you want, and to respectfully keep devs fed for finishing what we can't: https://forum.cloudron.io/topic/3380/sponsoring-n8n
-
It may end up that Huginn is the better option. Not sure, but that's a Ruby/Rails app too (my primary speciality) so perhaps I can look at getting that packaged so a bit of comparison can begin. Honestly not sure where that rings in on my priority list for the time being though. Reasonably low through the early parts of next year, likely.
-
@jimcavoli happy to sponsor if you do. We did trial it and ended up sticking with NodeRED.
TBH, with ETL tools, it's inevitable to use multiple as the time-saving from having read-made connectors offsets the cost of having different automations in different tools, hence we still run 4 and would likely hedge bets, continuing to use each for their advantages than limiting ourselves to just one.
-
@jimcavoli Nice work and insight. Does this development change anything for your view on the limitations of basic auth? https://forum.cloudron.io/topic/3682/proxyauth-addon
As far as "Some stuff only works in Chrome". I guess that covers all Chromiums, as I tend to use Vivaldi in those cases.
As with all these Apps, I can get some developer assistance if we need to also contribute direct to the apps themselves, so it's always worth having them available in the App Store as "Unstable" so we can review these things and contribute upstream with sponsorship or dev-time as well if necessary.
We're not here for a long time - but we are here for a good time :)
Jersey/UK
Work & Ecommerce Advice: https://brandlight.org
Personal & Software Tips: https://marcusquinn.com -
@marcusquinn Yeah, maybe the new auth wall is enough. Haven't tried adding it to this packaging yet, but that could be a reasonable solution, since this is otherwise fairly ready to go and has a lot of asks.
-
@jimcavoli think you could pick this up for a little sponsoring contribution? I think @murgero has other understandable priorities at the mo, so I prefer not to chase.
https://forum.cloudron.io/topic/3380/sponsoring-n8n
We have can jump in and start using and looking at core contributions as well once it's running and we can battle test. We have more devs on our team that can get into packaging but right now they are all flat-out on a bunch of systems migrations.
-
I think this one should just wait for Cloudron@6 and use the integrated proxyAuth. It does not seem reasonable to come up with a custom solution just to roll-back in a few weeks
-
@mehdi fair enough. I'm working on getting more Dev attention to help on Cloudron stuff too, takes a little time but as soon as anyone gets involved they do see the light
-
I'm reworking this now that 6 is out and
proxyAuthis an option. Currently got the latest version building and running on the latest node. Waiting for some details on how to doproxyAuthconfiguration to not break webhooks (rather important for this one!) and then I'll need to get to fixing up the websockets, but overall is looking okay. Switching from file-based to env-based configuration only because it seems better supported by the docs as well. -
-
@jimcavoli would love to see this in action! It seems that your repo hasn't been updated in a while (I'm only seeing 1 commit there) and the 'active connection to the server' isn't working so I'm not able to run any workflows. Keeping an eye on this for sure. Thanks!
-
Incredibly excited for this! Thanks for your hard work!!!
-
@jimcavoli @girish @nebulon I just had my Open AI beta application accepted!!
Get me n8n.io on Cloudron and I'll get amazing GPT-3 things built for you!
We're not here for a long time - but we are here for a good time :)
Jersey/UK
Work & Ecommerce Advice: https://brandlight.org
Personal & Software Tips: https://marcusquinn.com -
@marcusquinn said in n8n.io - Zappier, IFTTT, Integromat alternative:
I'll get amazing GPT-3 things built for you!
Sounds intriguing, what are you thinking?
-
@jdaviescoates I think Chatbots are the obvious one but there's a few applications:
- Message/Email context/sentiment analysis for tagging and directing to appropriate staff or place.
- Chat via email.
- CRM enrichment taking all known text from a person and writing a summary.
- Monitoring Social Media for inflammatory messages.
For fun:
Bold text is what you input, the rest is what is written for you:
Or I could ask GPT-3 to answer on my behalf
-
A bit more fun with GPT-3:
-
@jimcavoli Hey, how's it going with this? Have you hit any blockers? Just curious if we might see this any time soon. THANK YOU!
-
Im also curious about this. I threw together this guy: https://git.cloudron.io/AtriLahiji/n8n-app
And by threw together I mean I forked @jimcavoli 's repo, bumped the app version and base image version, and added proxyAuth. Just playing around with it now to see if there are issues. As you mentioned earlier there are probably webhook issues. How were you thinking of getting around this?
-
@atrilahiji I think that's one of the reasons why the exception flags were added to proxyauth, but you'd need to stick to default naming to not break the thing, @jimcavoli suggested that here.
