Password Protected Cloudron Nginx

[mehdi]

@oj Transmission at-least is already behind authentication

[nebulon]

Yes, also surfer has a way to password or user protect the public pages. So I wonder if this falls into the app's area to be implemented or a platform feature.

[oj]

@nebulon Generally put an app behind a login page.

[nebulon]

@oj ah ok, that is indeed easier then. Still there are at least two choices, we could enable the authproxy addon for apps where it makes sense or we could essentially allow the authproxy for any app. I would prefer a more selective approach, but maybe I don't see all the use-cases. For example putting a matomo behind an auth proxy blindly would essentially render the app useless as far as I can tell.

[oj]

@nebulon Yes, I see that my Surfer now has a "Password Restricted" option...Thanks! (I don't think it had it when I set it up over a year ago!)

[oj]

@nebulon Agree.

Essentially, my country's Information Technology rules (and punitive legal actions) have moved towards a concept of "intermediary liability" for the public actions of the users of the services that I host! Hosting and public distribution of so-called "anti-national" content (i.e. content critical of the governments policies/actions) is one such area...if you can believe it! (It may be difficult to believe this if you are in Europe!)

I have no control over these rules...So, as a service provider - in case of a specific, legally binding notice from the government - I could need to control who creates/distributes/reads content via these apps on Cloudron.

[girish]

I have added proxyAuth it some apps like file pizza and hastebin now. We can add it to more as we go. Jirafeau already has some admin page, so I think it will be confusing if we have a login page and another admin password page. jirafeau already has a way to restrict uploads - https://docs.cloudron.io/apps/jirafeau/#restricting-uploads . Maybe one of those will be enough. Alternately, I think we have to look into integrating better with the app somehow.

[oj]

@girish Thanks! Have rolled out filepizza... and users love the login experience! Hope Jirafeau too gets the same.

[lucidfox]

I'd like to add the password protection to file pizza as well. Seems like I might be missing an obvious setting, but how can can the proxyauth be activated?

[girish]

@lucidfox you have to re-install the app. when installing, it gives you the option to password protect or not.

[lucidfox]

@girish thanks for that, it worked. i'm not sure how useful the password protection is in practice, at least in my case, because the receiver of the file pizza link would also need to sign in (and not just the uploader). i've gone back to using file pizza without having to login. wondering if this a security risk in anyway?

[girish]

@lucidfox AFAIK, since it's totally peer to peer, there is no risk. Of course, external users can use it but no data goes through your server.