List of apps that support LDAP/Cloudron User Directory?
-
Is there a way to see which apps in the Cloudron store support LDAP or the Cloudron user directory?
-
Is there a way to see which apps in the Cloudron store support LDAP or the Cloudron user directory?
@humptydumpty not really, that would require a new filter in the appstore view. The info is of course available, but not really exposed in a list view.
-
@humptydumpty not really, that would require a new filter in the appstore view. The info is of course available, but not really exposed in a list view.
-
@nebulon no problem, I'll do the good old manual install and check method
@humptydumpty I think @jdaviescoates requested that here - https://forum.cloudron.io/topic/2069/filter-apps-in-app-store
-
@humptydumpty I think @jdaviescoates requested that here - https://forum.cloudron.io/topic/2069/filter-apps-in-app-store
-
@girish indeed. And given it sounds like this should be relatively trivial to add, and since newer similar requests have been implemented, I'm a little bemused that it hasn't been added already!
@jdaviescoates ha ha
The filters have to be made using data from the manifest. The opensource/license thing is not available. We will have to go through each app and update the manifest to create the filter.As for the the LDAP thing, it is readily available since it's part of CloudronManifest.json but it's not clear how useful this is. AFAIK, most people choose the app first and "live" with it's limitations. But I understand there's possible some small cases where a decision is based on LDAP.
-
@jdaviescoates ha ha
The filters have to be made using data from the manifest. The opensource/license thing is not available. We will have to go through each app and update the manifest to create the filter.As for the the LDAP thing, it is readily available since it's part of CloudronManifest.json but it's not clear how useful this is. AFAIK, most people choose the app first and "live" with it's limitations. But I understand there's possible some small cases where a decision is based on LDAP.
@girish If we have to go through each manifest to add the open source/licence metadata, my wish would be to add the licence specifically. e.g.
Ackee
Version: 3.3.1
Required minimum memory: 256MB
Last updated 17 Jan 2022
Website - Forum - Documentation - MIT-License -
@jdaviescoates ha ha
The filters have to be made using data from the manifest. The opensource/license thing is not available. We will have to go through each app and update the manifest to create the filter.As for the the LDAP thing, it is readily available since it's part of CloudronManifest.json but it's not clear how useful this is. AFAIK, most people choose the app first and "live" with it's limitations. But I understand there's possible some small cases where a decision is based on LDAP.
@girish said in List of apps that support LDAP/Cloudron User Directory?:
AFAIK, most people choose the app first and "live" with it's limitations. But I understand there's possible some small cases where a decision is based on LDAP.
That's where I stand atm. I started out with apps that suited my use-case the most but there are a ton of new apps added to the store so the selection just got bigger and when most of these apps are installed under the same domain with each having its own credentials, my password manager is getting cluttered.
In addition to that, I have to manage my family's credentials for most of these apps too. I end up sharing the login info by adding them to my vaultwarden "collection" which works great but I'm staring at 4x more logins. I literally have to scroll now to find my own. I never really appreciated the value of LDAP until now.
-
@girish said in List of apps that support LDAP/Cloudron User Directory?:
AFAIK, most people choose the app first and "live" with it's limitations. But I understand there's possible some small cases where a decision is based on LDAP.
That's where I stand atm. I started out with apps that suited my use-case the most but there are a ton of new apps added to the store so the selection just got bigger and when most of these apps are installed under the same domain with each having its own credentials, my password manager is getting cluttered.
In addition to that, I have to manage my family's credentials for most of these apps too. I end up sharing the login info by adding them to my vaultwarden "collection" which works great but I'm staring at 4x more logins. I literally have to scroll now to find my own. I never really appreciated the value of LDAP until now.
@humptydumpty besides the filter as such, it always helps a bit, if upstream issues about LDAP support are created for apps which do not support it yet. These things usually take time, but in the end it improves the situation for everyone.
-
@jdaviescoates ha ha
The filters have to be made using data from the manifest. The opensource/license thing is not available. We will have to go through each app and update the manifest to create the filter.As for the the LDAP thing, it is readily available since it's part of CloudronManifest.json but it's not clear how useful this is. AFAIK, most people choose the app first and "live" with it's limitations. But I understand there's possible some small cases where a decision is based on LDAP.
@girish said in List of apps that support LDAP/Cloudron User Directory?:
@jdaviescoates ha ha The filters have to be made using data from the manifest. The opensource/license thing is not available. We will have to go through each app and update the manifest to create the filter.
I'd still like that filter, but this thread is about an LDAP filter...
@girish said in List of apps that support LDAP/Cloudron User Directory?:
As for the the LDAP thing, it is readily available since it's part of CloudronManifest.json
Like I said, it sounds relatively trivial to add a filter for this.
but it's not clear how useful this is. AFAIK, most people choose the app first and "live" with it's limitations. But I understand there's possible some small cases where a decision is based on LDAP.
LDAP integrations between the apps is one of Cloudron's killer features!
Sure, I also use apps that don't have LDAP, but I still want to easily be able to see which ones have it and which don't. Clearly @humptydumpty would like that too (and I presume @RoundHouse1924 @yusf @thetomester13 @will @ruihildt @smokeyfro would too, given they've like the requests Humpty and I have made).
Given it would help to show off one of Cloudron's core USPs (imho) I can't think what could possibly be stopping you from wanting to do it quick sharp!
-
As much as I'd like to have a LDAP filter, I was only looking for a quick and dirty way. Girish mentioned something about that info being in the manifest. Where can I find that info? I assume it's easier than installing each app to figure that out, right?
-
As much as I'd like to have a LDAP filter, I was only looking for a quick and dirty way. Girish mentioned something about that info being in the manifest. Where can I find that info? I assume it's easier than installing each app to figure that out, right?
@humptydumpty https://api.cloudron.io/api/v1/apps/ has the apps in JSON format. You have to look for
manifest.addons.ldapinside each app. You can also get individual app like https://api.cloudron.io/api/v1/apps/org.navidrome.cloudronapp -
@humptydumpty not really, that would require a new filter in the appstore view. The info is of course available, but not really exposed in a list view.
@nebulon said in List of apps that support LDAP/Cloudron User Directory?:
The info is of course available, but not really exposed in a list view.
Please expose it! This is long overdue imho
-
N nebulon referenced this topic on
-
(I was replying to this other thread @briankb-0 started on App Support for LDAP (Cloudron Auth) when @nebulon locked the topic as a dupe of this one, so replying here instead):
Is there a list of what apps support LDAP?
No, but there really ought to be!
Upvote and chime into these thread:
List of apps that support LDAP/Cloudron User Directory?
https://forum.cloudron.io/post/43055Filter apps in app store by user management (LDAP) and license
https://forum.cloudron.io/post/5340@briankb-0 said in App Support for LDAP (Cloudron Auth):
I know Ghost does not, but Discourse does.
I got excited there for a moment because I and others been asking for/ wondering about LDAP for Discourse for ages!
Alas whilst it's technically feasible in that there are LDAP plugins out there for Discourse (although I'm not sure there are any particularly actively maintained ones, there are definitely people out there using Discourse with LDAP)
See these threads:
How to configure LDAP in Discourse?
https://forum.cloudron.io/post/7783LDAP for Discourse (and NodeBB)
https://forum.cloudron.io/post/27660What about Wiki.js or Ackee?
The only way to check at present is to click install and see what User management options come up.
Wiki.js does:
Ackee doesn't. No User management here, just Dashboard visibility:
-
For a start I have update the appstatus page to include a checkmark for apps which have LDAP enabled at https://www.cloudron.io/appstatus.html
-
For a start I have update the appstatus page to include a checkmark for apps which have LDAP enabled at https://www.cloudron.io/appstatus.html
@nebulon said in List of apps that support LDAP/Cloudron User Directory?:
For a start
There's more?
I think that list fits the bill perfectly. Thank you! -
@nebulon said in List of apps that support LDAP/Cloudron User Directory?:
For a start
There's more?
I think that list fits the bill perfectly. Thank you! -
For a start I have update the appstatus page to include a checkmark for apps which have LDAP enabled at https://www.cloudron.io/appstatus.html
@nebulon said in List of apps that support LDAP/Cloudron User Directory?:
For a start I have update the appstatus page to include a checkmark for apps which have LDAP enabled at https://www.cloudron.io/appstatus.html
Thanks!
@nebulon said in List of apps that support LDAP/Cloudron User Directory?:
@humptydumpty I do think it might be nice to have a filter directly in the app library listing within the dashboard. I think I will add this for the next release.
Agreed, thanks!
